3 ms·
I remember working, ~20 years ago, on a research project that involved creating a simulation of the device that was used at UK AGR nuclear plants to automatical
by arethuza 13y ago
I remember working, ~20 years ago, on a research project that involved creating a simulation of the device that was used at UK AGR nuclear plants to automatically shutdown plants in an emergency (I think it was called the RSSSE - Reactor Safety Shutdown Sequencing Equipment).
The plants were designed in the 1960s and, for such a critical task, they wanted to be very conservative about the designs. So they didn't even use electronics - it was all relays and mechanical gearing!
- johnchristopher 13y agoWouldn't it be harder to maintain relays and moving gears than some electronics equipment for which maintenance checks only involve running software through the circuits and check if green lights are blinking on the other side ? My point is: isn't it far easier and more reliable to trust electronics than moving parts ? Moreover you can check out electronics as much as you want while mechanical parts would tend to degrade for each test. Disclaimer: I known next to nothing about nuclear plants and plant maintenance.
- arethuza 13y ago"isn't it far easier and more reliable to trust electronics than moving parts" Possibly now - but I can see that back in the 1960s they probably had a point.
- johnchristopher 13y agoTrue.