3 ms·
Anyone familiar with the constitutional law on this? From a laymen's perspective it seems obvious that the government has some ability to restrict 1st amendmen
by slg 13y ago
Anyone familiar with the constitutional law on this? From a laymen's perspective it seems obvious that the government has some ability to restrict 1st amendment rights on matters of national security. If that wasn't the case, there would be no way to enforce legal restrictions on classified information. It would be the end of all government secrets, both good and bad. Or is this debate simply about where the actual line is drawn for national security and whether this this type of disclosure crosses that line?
- zachrose 13y agoHere's a place to start: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strict_scrutiny http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strict_scrutiny National security most likely qualifies as "compelling state interest" in general, but it's not the only thing the government needs to infringe on constitutional rights. The government also needs to prove that the infringement is narrow and specific. Even then, I wonder if the "compelling state interest" could be challenged on not being compelling enough. (I am definitely not a lawyer, just remembering a con law class I took and refreshing my memory with Wikipedia.)
- andrewfong 13y agoI'm a lawyer, although not one that regularly practices First Amendment law. That said, zachrose is right that strict scrutiny applies here. Usually, to restrict truthful speech based on the content of the speech, the government must show that (1) there is a compelling state interest and (2) that the government's restriction on speech is narrowly tailored. National security is pretty compelling, but it's unclear how prohibiting disclosure of the number of requests is narrowly tailored to that interest. Without knowing more details about the nature of the program, it's hard to say why the number matters. But if the NSA can't demonstrate how disclosing a specific number, as opposed to an approximate range, has a noticeable impact on national security, the law would likely not be in their favor.
- icambron 13y agoI guess I don't really understand "national security is compelling". National security, like basically everything else, is a matter of degree. There are presumably compelling and uncompelling national security risks. If the court is weighing some amount of speech restriction against some amount of national security risk, presumably the size of the risk matters? What are the governments burdens here? Can they merely assert there's a security issue here or do they have to prove it? Does it have to pass some kind of severity test in order to restrict speech? I'm genuinely curious what the case law says on this stuff.
- anigbrowl 13y agoHere's some useful historical context with good legal references but written for the lay person: http://www.freedomforum.org/templates/document.asp?documentID=15746 http://www.freedomforum.org/templates/document.asp?documentI...
- caf 13y agoMost restrictions on classified information are enforceable because those with access to the information have voluntarily surrended their first amendment rights in respect of classified information as part of the agreement they entered into when they obtained a security clearance. It's much less clear when you are talking about someone who hasn't agreed to the clearance process. In 1979 the Department of Energy tried to prevent The Progressive magazine from publishing an article by Howard Morland describing the design of the Hydrogen Bomb. The article was derived from unclassified sources, but the government argued that information about atomic weapon design is "born classified". There was no conclusive judgement, as the government eventually dropped the case and the article was published.