4 ms·
And what about their "we can search everything you have within a 100-mile radius of the border" policy? That's a huge civil liberties abuse too and one that mus
by mtgx 13y ago
And what about their "we can search everything you have within a 100-mile radius of the border" policy? That's a huge civil liberties abuse too and one that must be dealt with.
- rayiner 13y agoThat is not now and never has been the policy. The "100 mile Constitution free zone" is one of the most outrageously misleading fabrications on the internet. See: http://blog.constitutioncenter.org/2013/02/does-a-constitution-free-zone-really-exist-in-america http://blog.constitutioncenter.org/2013/02/does-a-constituti.... You can't leave out the crucial bit that it's all about border searches, for people who have recently crossed the border. All the policy means is that border searches don't literally have to occur at the border (they might be on a major cross-border thoroughfare somewhat inland). The 4th amendment has never meant that the government or customs needs a warrant to search people at the border.
- mikeash 13y agoI'd like to know, why doesn't the 4th amendment mean that? It seems pretty clear, and there's no such exclusion listed.
- rayiner 13y agoThe 4th amendment says: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." It doesn't read: "all searches require a warrant except those specifically listed." The text plainly allows searches that are not "unreasonable." As a matter of historical practice, borders searches, for customs purposes and otherwise, are considered reasonable. Warrant-less border searches were authorized by the First Congress in 1789.
- mikeash 13y agoThanks. I have to wonder just how you can say that a search which would be unreasonable if performed at e.g. a county border becomes reasonable at a country border.
- rayiner 13y agoBecause counties are administrative units, while countries are sovereign entities. One of the fundamental characteristics of a sovereign is the establishment and policing of a border. What it means to be a "country" is, among other things, some people getting together to use force to keep other people out. This was the framers' understanding of the world, a world of sovereign entities with borders and a right to police them. Within this framework of understanding, you can't say you don't reasonably expect not to be subject to a search when crossing a border. One of the basic purposes of the Constitution was to invest the federal government with primacy with respect to the national border: preserving it (collective defense), regulating the shipment of goods through it, taxing the shipment of goods through it (customs), etc. Indeed, one of the primary ways the federal government was to be funded was through taxes on imports, which implies the existence of a customs function at the border. Do you think the framers envisioned a customs system that couldn't enforce its tariffs without getting a court order to search incoming ships? They obviously didn't envision that, because one of the first things Congress did was to set up the framework for warrant-less customs searches.
- mikeash 13y agoOK, I think that makes sense. I would generally object to an appeal to tradition like this, but it seems to me that the use of the word "reasonable" is basically an explicit call out to tradition, so I guess that's just how it's written. Do you know what, if any, limits are placed on border searches? Is literally anything "reasonable" there, or are the limits just different?
- rayiner 13y agoThe common law process is by its nature an appeal to tradition. If there is a governing principle in our society, it's "this is okay because we've always done it this way." Yes, in a way it's ridiculous because we end up arguing about what people thought about border searches in 1789, but that's the nature of our society. We don't come to a consensus to solve problems, because we never agree on anything. Instead, we litigate them and grudgingly accept the outcomes. That's why court cases feature so prominently in our culture (Brown v. Board, Roe v. Wade, etc). Non-Americans, understandably, usually find it utterly bizarre. Re: border searches, I'm not well-versed so I'll just point you to the wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception. Long story short, it still has to be reasonable, it's just that the bar is lowered because you should expect to get searched at a border.
- rosser 13y agoYou can't leave out the crucial bit that it's all about border searches, for people who have recently crossed the border. Are you suggesting that if I haven't recently crossed a border, I'm somehow immune to these searches, or have a right to refuse them?
- rayiner 13y agohttp://www.texasobserver.org/border-patrol-takes-no-for-an-answer-at-internal-checkpoints http://www.texasobserver.org/border-patrol-takes-no-for-an-a... http://www.flexyourrights.org/faqs/my-rights-at-checkpoints/ http://www.flexyourrights.org/faqs/my-rights-at-checkpoints/
- rosser 13y agoThanks for these. From the first article, according to a CBP spokesman: “Although motorists are not legally required to answer the questions ‘are you a U.S. citizen and where are you headed,’ they will not be allowed to proceed until the inspecting agent is satisfied that the occupants of vehicles traveling through the checkpoint are legally present in the U.S.” That suggests to me that CBP, at least, sees these stops as rather custodial.
- makomk 13y agoThat second article is definitely less than honest on some of its other points - for example, it turns out that drug dogs in the US alert when their handler wants them to rather than on finding drugs, so if the police have a drug dog with them they can effectively search the car of anyone they take a dislike to. I'm curious as to whether it's omitting important details about the DHS checkpoints too.
- jellicle 13y ago> You can't leave out the crucial bit that it's all about border searches, for people who have recently crossed the border. Sadly, this is entirely false. The Border Patrol routinely sets up suspicion-less searches on Interstate 5 in California, 60 miles from the US border with Mexico. The vast majority of those stopped and searched are U.S. citizens who have not crossed the border recently.
- davepage 13y agoThis is one of the most outrageously false and misleading posts I have encountered on here. http://www.aopa.org/News-and-Video/All-News/2013/May/23/Fresh-reports-of-aircraft-searches-CBP-has-little-to-say http://www.aopa.org/News-and-Video/All-News/2013/May/23/Fres... Further, Iowa City is a long way from the border. 400 miles, perhaps.
- __--__ 13y agoBecause nobody's mentioned it yet, this has already been dealt with. There's a legal precedent: Ameida-Sanchez v. US But the search of the petitioner's automobile by a roving patrol, on a California road that lies at all points at least 20 miles north of the Mexican border,[5] was of a wholly different sort. In the absence of probable cause or consent, that search violated the petitioner's Fourth Amendment right to be free of "unreasonable searches and seizures."