4 ms·
Whether or not FB is deliberately blocking Tor now, how out-of-line would it be for them to eventually block it in the future? It doesn't seem in their best in
by danso 13y ago
Whether or not FB is deliberately blocking Tor now, how out-of-line would it be for them to eventually block it in the future?
It doesn't seem in their best interest as a company to allow Tor connections...but other than that, what ethical obligations do they have to allow anonymous connections? FB already has a policy more-or-less mandating real identities...so for them, this is kind of a non-issue, right? By using FB, you're already identifying yourself and agreeing to implicitly under the TOS.
So does that mean activists are screwed? Well...I'm interested in the use-cases for activists using FB...I mean, if you're in a situation where you fear the authorities tracking you down...then you hopefully have better sense than to conduct business under your social identity. If you're managing a FB account from a fake identity and fear the authorities tracking your IP...then maybe do your work from a public wifi? Facebook isn't your biggest enemy here...the enemy is, ostensibly, the government...and the secondary enemy is you (or your collaborators) attracting attention to yourself inadvertently, whether you're using Tor or not.
I guess the tl:dr of my question is: if you must conduct sensitive work, why do it on Facebook, a network that is committed to sharing things in public?
- badclient 13y agoif you must conduct sensitive work, why do it on Facebook, a network that is committed to sharing things in public? You might as well replace "facebook" with "the Internet".
- rpedroso 13y agoIt's not just a use-case for anonymous or clandestine activists. Consider the Arab Spring, where Facebook and especially Twitter were used to rally people together in public areas. Many countries might block large, uncensored social websites (like Facebook). Tools like Tor can help circumvent such practices.
- brownbat 13y ago> Whether or not FB is deliberately blocking Tor now, how out-of-line would it be for them to eventually block it in the future? > tl;dr: Why use Tor + FB? Fair point, there may only be some arcane use cases for the combo, but the dilemma becomes far more stark at: "How out-of-line would it be for users of the internet writ large to aggressively block IP addresses associated with malicious activity?" There was a call to "name and shame" DDOS participants a few months back, with the argument that every operator has the obligation to keep their "systems in trim." http://bsdly.blogspot.ca/2012/12/ddos-bots-are-people-or-manned-by-some.html http://bsdly.blogspot.ca/2012/12/ddos-bots-are-people-or-man... I was enamored with the idea. AV blacklists code, why not source? The AV industry has learned (for the most part) that sharing malware samples is for the good of everyone. But victims tend to stay silent about the IPs that participated in a DDOS, or worse, launched targeted intrusions. Why not build a list of pariah IPs and refuse to talk to them until they get their act together? Turns out that puts radical constraints on some useful projects, like Tor. Bot farmers might accidentally DDOS not only their target, but all of Tor if exit nodes were quickly blacklisted. Possibly worse, a government could intentionally spew noisy malicious activity through the network to get the endpoints shut down with deniability. Is it possible for a Tor exit node to "keep their system in trim?" Preventing its use as a gateway for malicious activity? You could make a crippled Tor that only allows a certain limited set of services, but that's not really Tor anymore. Anyone have a way to address: a) policing malware by IP addresses while b) allowing deniability of communication that's better than just giving up on one priority or the other?
- dspillett 13y ago> I guess the tl:dr of my question is: if you must conduct sensitive work, why do it on Facebook, a network that is committed to sharing things in public? If you are an activist you probably want the information shared with the public. You just might not be as keen for your identity to be shared with the people who find your activism inconvenient.
- bpatrianakos 13y agoI don't think it would be out of line at all. I got downvoted to hell for expressing similar opinions before but I think this is a perfectly reasonable opinion. Facebook is in the business of social networking, not activism. The number of users using Tor compared to the general population is bound to be so low that they either shouldn't care enough to bother blocking it or if they did for some reason, really wouldn't put a dent in their daily actives. Activists very well could be screwed, but that's really not Facebook's concern. Their no pseudonym policy makes perfect sense. Whether or not you like it or would use services that enforce it is an entirely separate issue. I feel like I don't have to explain this but I will anyway. Using a real name helps them help you find people you know (or at least whose name you know). That's the whole point. To start implementing policies conducive to anonymity defeats the entire purpose of Facebook. I understand why Facebook is such a great tool for activists and dissidents and why a social network built especially for those people would not be ideal. That said, at the end of the day Facebook has no obligation to support such people. The fact that it's such a great tool for activists is just a side effect of the app's main purpose and use by the general population. I'd even go so far as to say that if they blocked Tor purposely in the future no one would really have any right to be outraged. I mean, you can certainly and understandably be outraged, but you really can't say Facebook has wronged you as being a tool for activists isn't really their mission. Complaining that Facebook wants to collect info to show you ads is like complaining that the coffee shop requires that you give them money to be served. Tracking is the way you pay to use Facebook and I doubt they'd ever implement paid accounts to get rid of the tracking and ads. I'm sure there are some who work at Facebook who feel a moral obligation to support those activities but at the end of the day its a business and it isn't a business founded upon principles that fall in line with those of activists. If Mozilla created a social network, maybe then we could say the company has a moral obligation to encourage anonymity where people wanted but that kind of philosophy is just not in Facebook's DNA. if you must conduct sensitive work, why do it on Facebook, a network that is committed to sharing things in public? Because of exactly that. It's public and the general population uses it for an entirely different reason. If you're doing sensitive work and need to get the message out then Facebook is a great tool for the job so long as you can remain anonymous. I know that's totally contradictory sounding but it's reasonably possible. Currently you can use Tor and other measures (assuming this issue is resolved) like using a fake name (which is technically a pseudonym but what I really mean is a name meant to look like a real person but isn't). Everyone uses it, you can let the world know important info, and though you can be rooted out, it makes it more difficult as you're a needle in a haystack. Compare this to a tool built specifically for activist communication - it's basically a big honeypot for unfriendly governments. They know that every user is a political dissident and now they really don't have to narrow down their search. They can just start hacking and tracking every user on the site.
- ars 13y ago> Whether or not FB is deliberately blocking Tor now, how out-of-line would it be for them to eventually block it in the future? ... FB already has a policy more-or-less mandating real identities...so for them, this is kind of a non-issue, right? Those two are not the same. Even if they want to know your name, it doesn't follow that they automatically should get to know where you are (i.e. your IP).