6 ms·
As a person coming from a former Soviet republic - it reminds me of times 30 years ago, where the usual conversation with any official would look like this : "
by gambiting 13y ago
As a person coming from a former Soviet republic - it reminds me of times 30 years ago, where the usual conversation with any official would look like this :
"no"
"why?"
"because the government says so"
No trial, no hearing, someone somewhere in secret made the decision and you had nothing to say in that matter. Or if you tried, you would be charged with interfering with government business, or "national security" and jailed for a random amount of time.
Really that different to what the US government is doing right now?
- vxNsr 13y agoYeah but at least in the USSR you could bribe your way out of this type of situation. Here it's even worse because the people at the bottom (checking counter people) wont take bribes and maybe even can't because the computer will stop them from entering certain info.
- nathan_long 13y agoGiving a bribe might make a specific situation easier for you, but having a system where bribes are tolerated is cancerous. Few things have such power to destroy a nation.
- vinceguidry 13y agoOne could argue that the nation was already long gone by the time that happened. Corruption is just accelerating the inevitable.
- potatolicious 13y agoBrokenness at a high level can be fixed. Brokenness as a result of rampant corruption at all levels cannot. You can restore civil liberties by enacting or repealing laws. You can't do it when no effective executive mechanism exists (i.e., all your bureaucrats, police, and other officials are on the dole). Widespread corruption, IMO, is far more dangerous in the long term than what we're seeing right now in the US.
- nathan_long 13y agoYes. The people can demand that the government change policies. But if the people themselves are corrupt - the teacher won't teach and the doctor won't treat unless they're bribed - there's nobody left to fix things.
- ajross 13y agoObviously it's not different in principle, but in practice there are comparatively few people on the no-fly list, and the no-fly list is a comparatively unique mechanism. US citizens aren't typically prohibited from travelling, or corresponding with internationals, or publishing journals and notes, etc... Yes, this is bad. Yes it should be fixed. But let's check the "ZOMG WE'RE IN A COMMIE GULAG!" hyperbole at the door. The less seriously we take this the more reason the government has to pick the "sane compromise" position which involves no-fly lists and universal-but-mostly-invisible surveillance.
- astine 13y agoI don't think anyone's saying we're in a commie gulag, but the comparison is still valid. The vectors for abuse of government power are growing and our resources are shrinking. The problem is still bearable, but we're headed in the wrong direction nonetheless.
- frogpelt 13y agoI've found that people generally have a problem with certain types of comparisons. If I say Bush/Obama is similar to Hitler in ways X and Y people stop listening and get mad, even if the comparison is dead accurate. I think it is dangerous to dismiss those types of comparisons.
- dragonwriter 13y agoSuch comparisons are rhetorical devices to substitute emotional appeals for rational argument; its a good thing that people tend to dismiss them. Make the case for what the problem is with what Bush or Obama is doing, fine; after you've made the case use an example of an act of Nazi Germany that is genuinely similar in the relevant respects to make the point that the problem isn't merely theoretical, sure. But directly compare Bush/Obama to Hitler ... well, unless your goal is to provide an emotional boost to people who have already bought into the substance of your complaint, you shouldn't do that, and its quite right that people start tuning you out when you do that, especially when you open with it.
- 13y ago
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThere are some pretty large differences but it is similar enough that more and more people are making the comparison in conversation. Folks who have read up on the Mccarthy hearings on anti-american activities will see a similar pattern of public backlash developing. s/Communism/Terrorism/g right? It becomes easier and easier to recruit people to vote against the excesses and then these people get booted out of government. Can't happen fast enough for me
- regularfry 13y agoThe difference here is that there's no witch-hunt of high-profile, popular people to cause that backlash. Yet.