3 ms·
> "Enough with this old wives tale" was rude? And yet you used: "people like yourself", "trolls and egos", "lazy negative posts", "you've ignored everyone else
by laumars 13y ago
> "Enough with this old wives tale" was rude? And yet you used: "people like yourself", "trolls and egos", "lazy negative posts", "you've ignored everyone else that's replied to you", "you're not even interested in this subject anyway", "people who actually know what they're talking about on this matter",
You're selectively sampling data there. Those comments of mine are from later on in this debate - where you've been equally condescending. At the start I was polite.
> a) "not all users get the same results" -- I replied to this, testing the "personalised bubble" effect. What else exactly do you think is in play? Divine intervention?
Indeed you did. Albeit just the once. More tests would be required if you truly cared about disproving the bubble effect as your results could easily have fallen into the (b) point I raised.
> b) "popular results for similar search patterns will be biased in everyones results" -- irrelevant, since I used the very terms Tim Bray tried. Why weren't they "biased" in HIS results? Isn't he a member of "everyone"?
[sigh] Because they might not have been popular when he searched for them. His blog might have caused others to Google those terms and thus skew the results (in fact it definitely has caused others to Google his search terms as we're here arguing about it now). This is why I posted examples of other search terms, which you clearly haven't looked at yet. If you're not going to look at my examples, then why don't you try a few more irregular searches of your own.
In this whole argument you've basically taken one example as proof that your argument works every time. You've not even attempted other irregular search patterns of your own (or perhaps you have but they proved my point so you opted to ignore them as well?) so I really don't know how you can be so confident when you assert your point so absolutely. You do realise that multiple experiments need to be performed if you want to prove a statistical average? Just as myself and all the other Go developers have done with our time spent troubleshooting code.
> c) "not everyone uses Google." -- almost everybody does, and Tim for his examples used (and even works at) Google. Irrelevant again.
Of course it's relevant. You're arguing that "Go" is good enough on it's own - Google searches are just an example. If your point was valid then your results would be similar in other search engines. Later confining your point to one search engine seems a little like moving the goal posts mid-match.