2 ms·
No, the system is basically honest and above board. It just has quirks that would be made worse if they were "fixed". Our electoral system has evolved over the
by jacques_chester 13y ago
No, the system is basically honest and above board. It just has quirks that would be made worse if they were "fixed". Our electoral system has evolved over the past century to be, quite honestly, one of the most open, progressive and balanced electoral systems in the world.
What we in Australia call "exhaustive preferential voting" is sometimes called "instant runoff voting" elsewhere. Having to number every box is a feature, not a bug. If you don't have an exhaustive ballot, then in practice political parties will encourage voters to "just vote 1" -- to mark only one box.
And then you've arrived at a first-past-the-post system, which is what IRV is trying to get away from in the first place.
In the House of Reps, few candidates turn out because it's very difficult for a non-major party candidate to win. It happens, but only rarely. So in any given seat it would be unusual to find more than 5 or 6 candidates -- 2 majors, a green, whatever microparty is currently making a push and perhaps the local village idiot or somebody who doesn't realise that running as an independent is a mug's game.
But the Senate is different. The Senate is based on proportional representation. Each State elects 6 senators, and the Senate seats are effectively allocated to parties according to the final distribution of votes. In a recursive process, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated and their votes redistributed according to the voter preferences, up and up until there are 6 people with a full "quota" of votes.
The thing about the Senate is that the final Senate seat in any given state is usually in play. The top 4 seats are almost always won equally by the majors; the 5th usually won by a major or the Greens. But the 6th seats can and frequently do wind up in the hands of the most unlikely people because of the complicated preference deals I described above.
Because there is a chance for a microparty candidate to wind up in the Senate, lots of people run. Being a Senator is a pretty sweet deal. Good pay, your own offices and staff, travel entitlements and the like. And if you luck into holding the balance of power in the Senate, you've just become a very powerful individual.
- contingencies 13y agoThanks. I'm Australian, I just left very young and never really went back, and hold multiple other citizenships as well. Definitely going to hassle my local consulate about voting this election though.