3 ms·
Governments already (and appropriately) legislate all sorts of things about software. * Some governments require windows to present a choice of web browsers.
by x0x0 13y ago
Governments already (and appropriately) legislate all sorts of things about software.
* Some governments require windows to present a choice of web browsers.
* Some governments require websites, operating systems, or programs to provide for accessibility to the disabled.
Some governments also regulate information collection and sharing:
* Some governments (including the US) regulate what information credit card companies must provide to consumers.
* Some governments (including the US) regulate what info credit bureaus can collect, sell, require them to provide free copies on demand to those surveilled, and set up a framework for a dispute process.
It's perfectly reasonable for governments, as an agent of the people, to create laws and regulations around what can be collected and how. And yes, code may have to go into browsers to comply.
- handsomeransoms 13y agoThe long history of the interactions between relatively slow-moving governments and relatively fast-moving technology suggests that we should only legislate software as a last resort. One of the nice things about the proposed Do Not Track standard is that it requires no additional legislation. Once advertising bodies agree to some meaningful definition of DNT, any violations could be prosecuted using existing laws that protect consumers from deceptive advertising. Online tracking is a difficult problem without a purely technical solution available. Even with 3rd party cookies blocked, advertisers will still use first party cookies (Google, Facebook), or more sneaky and difficult to mititgate mechanisms (browser fingerprinting, evercookies) to track Internet users. Legislating is slow, uncertain, full of compromise, and riddled with conflicts of interest (hold the comparisons to the current DNT negotiations, please). While it is sometimes appropriate, or required as the only remaining recourse, it is far from an ideal solution - especially with a problem such as this where there is such an imbalance of influence between parties in Washington.