2 ms·
You're very fond of that "more legislation" metric, but it continues to overlook that this is a very poor metric. And it's inflated by the introduction of very
by jacques_chester 13y ago
You're very fond of that "more legislation" metric, but it continues to overlook that this is a very poor metric. And it's inflated by the introduction of very many new tax laws and amendments to tax laws, which the Constitution requires all be introduced in standalone bills.
- vacri 13y agoAnd you're very fond of handwaving it away as mere humdrum paperwork, conveniently ignoring the point that previous governments also did humdrum paperwork. The point is that the government is not paralysed by being a minority government. And it's not just a small amount more in the way of new bills, it's close to 40% more than the last term of the opposition in power. Even if it's inflated, it's still indicative that they're able to do stuff. Cut the number of bills passed in half and you still have a number competitive with any other modern government. I mean really, are you saying moves like curtailing middle-class welfare are meaningless legislation? I'm not saying that this government is particularly awesome, but I am saying that the picture painted of them by the media is remarkably off-kilter.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI'm saying that it's a meaningless metric that overlooks the quality of the legislation and that when you subtract the new tax Acts, it's around the long-term average. Conclusion: the government, which can scrape together a 1-vote majority ... can scrape together a 1-vote majority. Worrying about passing lots of bills or few bills is really silly because, as you pointed out, almost everything goes through on the nod anyhow. The amount of legislation that is genuinely rejected by Parliaments is miniscule. The government is able to command a majority of one vote: that's all it ever needs, especially with fellow-believers in Magic Pudding economics having the balance up in the Senate. I care less about the amount of activity and more about the quality. I don't think this has been a good government. I didn't think much of the previous one or the one before that. Hawke/Keating and the first 2 terms of Howard/Costello were about as good as this country's had so far. I also note that whatever their position in Parliament, the government is perfectly able to paralyse themselves quite without the help of the independents.
- vacri 13y agoBut that's the thing, I just don't see how the current government is paralysed. They're doing stuff. They've got an incredibly hostile media that keep saying they're paralysed based on... what? You yourself have just said 'so what, they're passing stuff, governments do that with even 1-vote majorities, but they're paralysed'. I can understand people not liking the legislation, but I don't understand the characterisation that the government is unable to move. It's been a little scary to watch the media over the past few years in this respect. As for meaningless metric, what other metrics do we have? Is not the quality of legislation a measure built almost entirely of opinion? I guess my problem is that the focus has almost wholly been on the soap opera of politics rather than the pointy end that actually affects the country. Only the barest mention of policy is required to try to explain the bad polling, which will then set off the next week's round of "the polls are bad because the polls are bad". There's also been a surprising amount of misogyny and general lack of respect throughout - which is another argument - but I note that I've never seen another PM referenced by first name so much. Hrm. Perhaps Gough, though I was in nappies when he was also run out of office :)
- jacques_chester 13y ago> * I just don't see how the current government is paralysed.* When the cabinet spends more time phoning each other to check numbers than acting in their roles as Ministers of the Crown, that's bad for business. Compare and contrast the dying days of Howard, when for several months Hamlet of Higgins hovered with a knife. > As for meaningless metric, what other metrics do we have? Process metrics aren't output metrics. More generally, I don't like a lot of the policy settings, so understandably I'm agin' it. I agree that the media of person and personality has crowded out everything else, including the discussion of whether the bills being presented advance the national interest. I think Gillard is quite sincere about the NDIS and Gonski and it's a pity that neither policy has received more than a fairly surface level consideration. I'm sure that an element of the bile directed towards Gillard is misogyny, but a lot of it is plain old politician-hate. I can't think of a single PM who hasn't been honest-to-god hated by at least 30% of the electorate.