2 ms·
Housing is simply not just another commodity. An utterly fundamental aspect of commodities is that their production is price-elastic, and governed by supply and
by twic 13y ago
Housing is simply not just another commodity. An utterly fundamental aspect of commodities is that their production is price-elastic, and governed by supply and demand: if demand increases, prices rise, so, supply increases, prices fall again, and the market remains efficient.
The housing supply has very little price elasticity, at least in London. This is for the very simple reason that there is hardly any space to build new housing, and enormous barriers to demolishing existing housing to free up such space. So, when prices go up, as they do every year, supply does not expand accordingly.
I'm sorry, but to brush the problem off with an assertion that houses are just another commodity is simply to advertise one's ignorance of economics.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- salmonellaeater 13y agoYou're right: I chose the wrong word. My point was more about the allocation of housing to the people willing to pay the most. I don't see why housing ought to be special in this regard; most things money can buy are sold at market prices.
- michaelochurch 13y agoThe housing supply has very little price elasticity, at least in London. Demand is also inelastic, which leads to some counterintuitive results. Let's say that you destroy 5% of housing (a catastrophic flood). Prices will double. Dumbasses will assume that housing became more desirable. ("People really want to live here! Prices are going up rapidly!") No, it just became scarcer. However if you conflate price and value, which most people do, that disaster (that reduces quantity by 5% but doubles prices) will be taken to cause a 90% improvement in "value". Wrong. See also: 9/11. After the terrorist attack, prices in Manhattan actually went up as speculators bet on future supply compromise/destruction in NYC real estate. There was a brief dip in Lower Manhattan (panic selling) but the more adept speculators bought, creating the morbid 9/11 Boom in NYC real estate. Slight margins in supply problems have huge price effects. That is the story of housing. That's why it's so infuriating when upper-middle-class people get rent control through connections. It's not that there are many of these people-- they're much less than 1%-- but that they have such a disproportionate impact. The global elite's parasitism is just one catastrophe that is driving up prices. It doesn't take many houses to be pulled off the market to push them up by huge amounts.