7 ms·
Attention NoScript users
- buugs 18y agoIt doesn't surprise me the extent some people go to to generate revenue in what I must think is a small market. I am an adblock plus user and I must say it enhances my browsing a noticeable amount that when I am using a different browser or no adblock I notice and although this is not ideal for websites that make money off of ads I really dislike them. Same can't be said for noscript I've stopped installing it on firefoxs I use and don't think I have it installed on any of my computers it just stopped being functional for me with firebug and adblock.
- thorax 18y ago> It doesn't surprise me the extent some people go to to generate revenue in what I must think is a small market. I agree there, but (and I'm in the minority here) it actually surprises me the extent the developers went to block ads in such a small corner situation. NoScript's behavior started out shady, but it feels like Adblock developers escalated it into some sort of weird war. A war against ads that appear only rarely and that only a small number of people probably noticed? Was that really necessary? It seems like you'd just uninstall NoScript if it was a major problem seeing their update pages. I mean, someone specifically installed NoScript and it could be serving ads from their local machine if it wanted, right? Do I really expect AdBlock to try to protect me from other extensions to such a level? I don't use either extension, but it bothers me that extension developers are turning this into a one-up-man-ship for something so minor in the scheme of things.
- Nwallins 18y ago> Adblock developers escalated it into some sort of weird war Some hyperbole for sure. Nothing gets around the fact that NoScript overstepped very clear and natural boundaries. If I had been the target, I would probably overreact as well. NoScript's behavior is nonetheless well worth pointing out and publicly shaming.
- thorax 18y agoNot hyperbole-- it's very much in our interest for these guys to sort this out publicly before escalation. It's irresponsible to cause a technical fight on your users machines. Essentially what I said here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=590263 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=590263
- spkthed 18y agoI don't think they did overreact. Noscripts function is to block scripts, Adblocks function is to block ads. They found a popular plugin that attacks their functionality and they took steps to combat it. I'm glad they did so. The major point behind all of this is that extensions should be an island. You shouldn't be messing with the work of anyone else, especially for the reasons they had here.
- thorax 18y agoYeah, they overreacted. NoScript shouldn't have started out that way. AdBlock Plus shouldn't have forced the issue by making it even more of an "island" war. They should have started with this kind of blog in the first place before escalating on the technical side. Note that NoScript could easily change their scheme to move further into their island where AdBlock Plus would be forced to invade fully-- it's in no one's interest to escalate before diplomacy has been worked through. The last thing we need is the light-smattering of gray Firefox addons (who are at worst showing some adsense ads) to be forced to push things deeper into darker areas. Imagine if this was Symantec and Trend? Microsoft or Apple? Do you really want them to be fighting technically on your machine? In principle, it's just fundamentally bad for us to encourage that kind of behavior. They should use diplomacy, and shine lights in the dark areas before escalating technically. Yes, NoScript reacted to the escalation fiendishly. I just don't think it was responsible on AdBlock Plus's side to escalate technically on such a minor issue when diplomacy/communication is so much better for everyone.
- spkthed 18y agoAdBlock Plus shouldn't have forced the issue by making it even more of an "island" war. They should have started with this kind of blog in the first place before escalating on the technical side. Okay, so, you do realize that Adblock faces spammers that are constantly trying to tweak the system to get through blockers like Adblock, right? It's a constant fight. How is what Noscript is doing any other than other spammers? Adblock is simply treating them as any other ad company that's trying to sneak ads in. Given that that is the reason people install Adblock, that's a perfectly appropriate response. The NoScript developers not only overreacted, they also acted incredibly against the wishes of the users installing both programs.
- ableal 18y agoMy method for this madness may be useful to someone. I use two browsers: A) Konqueror (aka Webkit/Chrome), with NO Java/Javascript/etc., for general reading and exploratory browsing. (Reads PDFs too, btw). B) Firefox for the "usual suspects". No extensions. No Flash either, but that's me. Problem solved. A surprising amount of the web works with A, some shops or social sites need B, I don't care about the rest.
- earl 18y agoYou should try flashblock, if you don't already know about it. Instead of loading flash you get a play button where the flash would have been and you can choose to turn it on if you want. It also supports whitelists, although annoyingly enough on the host of the flash, not on the website displaying the flash.
- ableal 18y agoThanks, I know it exists - I'm just stubborn ;-). I dislike opaque executable blobs delivered inside HTML, proprietary plugins to deal with them, and browser extensions to deal with the problems ... feels like piling bricks on moving sand - tiresome, ineffective, unsafe.
- dgallagher 18y agoJust to re-iterate the article, NoScript runs ads on their website to generate some revenue. Adblock Plus normally blocks these ads, but NoScript whitelists itself (along with a few other partner developer websites) in Adblock Plus "without" end-user permission, and without making a genuine effort to notify users it's doing this. It hacks Adblock Plus from working on its sites, basically. You can disable NoScript's "modification" to Adblock Plus by doing the following in Firefox: 1) Tools -> Add-ons -> Adblock Plus -> Preferences 2) Collapse the "Filter subscription: EasyList (USA)" list. 3) Uncheck "Enabled" for the "Filter subscription: NoScript Developer Support Filterset" list. Now when NoScript installs an update, and loads its webpage full of ads, Adblock Plus won't be blocked from doing its duty. Unless of course NoScript re-enables the filter...
- axod 18y agoOTOH It's trivial for any site to get past adblock if they choose to, or degrade the users experience if they're running adblock (If they have js). I've never understood the reason for installing NoScript. It seems utterly pointless. Why not install NoHTML while you're at it, or use lynx. Also never understood the philosophy behind adblock. If a website starts doing garish irritating ads, just don't go there again.
- simonw 18y agoThere's a very good reason to run NoScript: most web developers still don't understand CSRF, and hence many web applications are vulnerable to CSRF attacks. Running NoScript prevents untrusted sites from exploiting CSRF holes in sites that you care about. That said I don't personally run NoScript (I use Safari), but I totally understand people who do.
- dgallagher 18y agoFYI, the newest version of NoScript (1.9.2.6) stops doing this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=589683 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=589683
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- mustpax 18y agoVery revealing. I stopped using NoScript a while ago since it would not properly whitelist some sites. At the time I was wondering why the plugin was updated so frequently with very similar change logs each time. This post explains why. Interfering with other extensions' internal state is simply unacceptable. Firefox should consider sandboxing the browser extensions. Maybe they'll get to that after they implement Chrome style robust per tab sandboxing.
- just_the_tip 18y agoThe plugin is updated frequently also because doing so lands itself in the Most Popular Add-ons chart. Giorgio has a history of pushing the limit to see what he can get away before backtracking when someone calls him out on it.
- hboon 18y agoSounds like an entrepreneur trait.
- axod 18y ago>> "Interfering with other extensions' internal state is simply unacceptable" Interfering with other websites revenue models is also simply unacceptable by using adblock.
- jauco 18y agoNo it isn't! I'm allowed to ffwd past comercials using my VHS and to cut out ads on my newspaper. Ads are a soft form of brainwashing, making watching them compulsive sounds too much like "brave new world" to me.
- axod 18y ago>> "Ads are a soft form of brainwashing" Every input we receive to our brains could be said to be a soft form of brainwashing. Good advertising serves a use for consumers. Without it, you wouldn't be aware of what you can buy/do etc. If you want to opt out of that, fine. Personally, I find it invaluable to be aware of what is going on.
- illumen 18y agoAdblock also blocks the behaviour of no-script... by blocking the ads. Both are doing wrong in a way... but not in others. It's a contradiction, but neither can claim to be the white knights... both are at best grey.
- pyr3 18y agoNoScript's behavior isn't the display of ads though, so AdBlock is _not_ directly messing with NoScript. It could be that the users installed AdBlock to block the NoScript ads. In this case, NoScript is giving the finger to the users opinion. At some point when the default behavior of two programs with similar feature-sets overlaps you just have to leave resolving them as an exercise for the user. But targeting the other program in such a way is no different than someone installing two A/V softwares. Sure they may conflict in some areas, but if one of them silently disables or cripples the other on purpose... who is in the wrong?
- spkthed 18y agoOne of the big points in that article mirrors your example. The correct response is to allow the user to decide. "But targeting the other program in such a way is no different than someone installing two A/V softwares. Sure they may conflict in some areas" "This software program conflicts with this software program. You can choose to run them both and accept the problems that occur accordingly or you can choose to cancel this installation or remove program X" Do you want to cancel, remove program X, or cancel the installation? Give users the option to opt-into using your software, don't force users to get into a proxy battle by automatically opting into things.
- duskwuff 18y ago"But targeting the other program in such a way is no different than someone installing two A/V softwares. Sure they may conflict in some areas..." No. Hell no. Antivirus programs conflict for a good technical reason. NoScript and AdBlock conflict because the author of one dislikes the effects of the other program; were it not for that, the two extensions would be completely compatible with one another. Equating these two things with each other completely misses the point.