5 ms·

Django-registration 1.0 is out

66 points by kmfrk 13y ago

sammy_rulez 13y ago
Django registration is awesome but still no default templates ( or official companion project that provides them) I don't get it.
- huxley 13y ago
  The main developer James Bennett has discussed his reasons several times on multiple venues, but the FAQ in the Read the Docs for django-registration gives details in "Does django-registration come with any sample templates I can use right away?" https://django-registration.readthedocs.org/en/latest/faq.html#installation-and-setup https://django-registration.readthedocs.org/en/latest/faq.ht... Other people have provided good baselines to work from, the Djen of Django provides explanations with their samples: http://agiliq.com/books/djenofdjango/chapter5.html#reusable-apps http://agiliq.com/books/djenofdjango/chapter5.html#reusable-... (note I haven't upgraded to 1.0 so not sure if there are any incompatibilities)
  - sammy_rulez 13y ago
    Yes.. I have read the faq but 1 "Providing default templates with an application is generally hard to impossible" not true since the introducton of app template loader 2 "A number of things in django-registration depend on the specific registration backend" 99 % uses standard db/user built in backend. If you use social-auth or similar you (almost ) do not need registration I second 'yourcelf' comment below.. I always use his template as a starting point. May be a management commas that generate those default templates? ( not a big fan of template generation anyway)
- bmelton 13y ago
  I've used Django Registration on at least 5 projects, and despite having built a good set of templates with the first project, haven't ever been able to reuse them completely. Registration is (or at least, probably ought to be) a very personal set of decisions for any app/project. I agree that there could be some easily packaged, cookie-cutter defaults, but having experienced all the reasons James Bennett cited for not packaging any templates, I have to say that he's not crazy for their omission.
- yourcelf 13y ago
  Here's a set of default templates I wrote. I respect the reasoning for not providing them, but implementing 15 templates to get started out of the box is a bit onerous. https://github.com/yourcelf/django-registration-defaults https://github.com/yourcelf/django-registration-defaults
- zalew 13y ago
  if you want sth more complete, try django-userena.
arocks 13y ago
This has been a long awaited update for django-registration to make it compatible with Django 1.5's user model. To give some context, several people submitted pull requests over the last few months which were continually rejected. Glad to see this canonical Django package getting finally updated. Note: The documentation[1] still describes 0.9 version. [1]: https://django-registration.readthedocs.org/en/latest/ https://django-registration.readthedocs.org/en/latest/
- michaelmior 13y ago
  Isn't the documentation actually for 0.8?
- nobodyshere 13y ago
  Yep, for some reason they decided it would be ok to delay release and deny pull requests for so much time that many people (myself included) simply wrote their own implementations.
kmfrk 13y ago
I wanted to link to the changelog, but James (Ubernostrum), understandably, hasn't updated it yet.
OhWhyBother 13y ago
Django newbie here, how does Django-registrations compare to django-userena?
- ineedtosleep 13y ago
  From my quick stint with django-userena, it felt very constrained. At that time, my application's login requirements were simple, but needed a few minor tweaks. It's been a while, but I recall that doing so didn't seem like an easy task, so I switched to django-registration then eventually using the Django 1.5 custom user model. Overall, I'd say do a quick run through of both. If one of them has exactly what you need, stick with it. Otherwise, you are probably better off using the default User model or extending the default.
surfearth 13y ago
Is it now possible (and straightforward) to drop the requirement for a username and solely use email addresses for user accounts?
- orenbarzilai 13y ago
  Why not just enforce the username field to email syntax?
  - brianhicks 13y ago
    because prior to the new User implementation in 1.5, you couldn't change the length of the username CharField. Long emails wouldn't fit.
  - zalew 13y ago
    because of max_length=30
    - orenbarzilai 13y ago
      True! I changed it manually in the production DB.
truebosko 13y ago
Am I missing something, or is there a reason that the Django 1.5 implementation didn't stretch into other parts of the project, like the built-in RegistrationForm? It still uses the old User model directly. https://bitbucket.org/ubernostrum/django-registration/src/8f242e35ef7c004e035e54b4bb093c32bf77c29f/registration/forms.py?at=default https://bitbucket.org/ubernostrum/django-registration/src/8f...
amarsahinovic 13y ago
For the interested, overview of the user registration apps for Django: https://speakerdeck.com/tedtieken/signing-up-and-signing-in-users-in-django-with-django-allauth https://speakerdeck.com/tedtieken/signing-up-and-signing-in-...

66 points by kmfrk 13y ago

Django registration is awesome but still no default templates ( or official companion project that provides them) I don't get it.

huxley 13y ago
The main developer James Bennett has discussed his reasons several times on multiple venues, but the FAQ in the Read the Docs for django-registration gives details in "Does django-registration come with any sample templates I can use right away?" https://django-registration.readthedocs.org/en/latest/faq.html#installation-and-setup https://django-registration.readthedocs.org/en/latest/faq.ht... Other people have provided good baselines to work from, the Djen of Django provides explanations with their samples: http://agiliq.com/books/djenofdjango/chapter5.html#reusable-apps http://agiliq.com/books/djenofdjango/chapter5.html#reusable-... (note I haven't upgraded to 1.0 so not sure if there are any incompatibilities)
- sammy_rulez 13y ago
  Yes.. I have read the faq but 1 "Providing default templates with an application is generally hard to impossible" not true since the introducton of app template loader 2 "A number of things in django-registration depend on the specific registration backend" 99 % uses standard db/user built in backend. If you use social-auth or similar you (almost ) do not need registration I second 'yourcelf' comment below.. I always use his template as a starting point. May be a management commas that generate those default templates? ( not a big fan of template generation anyway)
bmelton 13y ago
I've used Django Registration on at least 5 projects, and despite having built a good set of templates with the first project, haven't ever been able to reuse them completely. Registration is (or at least, probably ought to be) a very personal set of decisions for any app/project. I agree that there could be some easily packaged, cookie-cutter defaults, but having experienced all the reasons James Bennett cited for not packaging any templates, I have to say that he's not crazy for their omission.
yourcelf 13y ago
Here's a set of default templates I wrote. I respect the reasoning for not providing them, but implementing 15 templates to get started out of the box is a bit onerous. https://github.com/yourcelf/django-registration-defaults https://github.com/yourcelf/django-registration-defaults
zalew 13y ago
if you want sth more complete, try django-userena.

arocks 13y ago

This has been a long awaited update for django-registration to make it compatible with Django 1.5's user model. To give some context, several people submitted pull requests over the last few months which were continually rejected. Glad to see this canonical Django package getting finally updated. Note: The documentation[1] still describes 0.9 version. [1]: https://django-registration.readthedocs.org/en/latest/ https://django-registration.readthedocs.org/en/latest/

michaelmior 13y ago
Isn't the documentation actually for 0.8?
nobodyshere 13y ago
Yep, for some reason they decided it would be ok to delay release and deny pull requests for so much time that many people (myself included) simply wrote their own implementations.

kmfrk 13y ago

I wanted to link to the changelog, but James (Ubernostrum), understandably, hasn't updated it yet.

OhWhyBother 13y ago

Django newbie here, how does Django-registrations compare to django-userena?

ineedtosleep 13y ago
From my quick stint with django-userena, it felt very constrained. At that time, my application's login requirements were simple, but needed a few minor tweaks. It's been a while, but I recall that doing so didn't seem like an easy task, so I switched to django-registration then eventually using the Django 1.5 custom user model. Overall, I'd say do a quick run through of both. If one of them has exactly what you need, stick with it. Otherwise, you are probably better off using the default User model or extending the default.

surfearth 13y ago

Is it now possible (and straightforward) to drop the requirement for a username and solely use email addresses for user accounts?

orenbarzilai 13y ago
Why not just enforce the username field to email syntax?
- brianhicks 13y ago
  because prior to the new User implementation in 1.5, you couldn't change the length of the username CharField. Long emails wouldn't fit.
- zalew 13y ago
  because of max_length=30
  - orenbarzilai 13y ago
    True! I changed it manually in the production DB.

truebosko 13y ago

Am I missing something, or is there a reason that the Django 1.5 implementation didn't stretch into other parts of the project, like the built-in RegistrationForm? It still uses the old User model directly. https://bitbucket.org/ubernostrum/django-registration/src/8f242e35ef7c004e035e54b4bb093c32bf77c29f/registration/forms.py?at=default https://bitbucket.org/ubernostrum/django-registration/src/8f...

amarsahinovic 13y ago

For the interested, overview of the user registration apps for Django: https://speakerdeck.com/tedtieken/signing-up-and-signing-in-users-in-django-with-django-allauth https://speakerdeck.com/tedtieken/signing-up-and-signing-in-...