2 ms·
You are drawing a distinction that does not legally exist. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Lopez http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v
by btilly 13y ago
You are drawing a distinction that does not legally exist.
See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Lopez http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Lopez and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Morrison http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Morrison fo examples of cases where a law was not directly prohibited by the Constitution, but part of it was still ruled unconstitutional because there was no argument from the Constitution granting Congress the authority to pass that law.
(In theory you could argue that it was prohibited under the 10th. But the arguments made by the court would apply regardless of the presence of the 10th.)
- dllthomas 13y agoThat's orthogonal. My point is that calling something that is prohibited by law but could, without changing the constitution, not be prohibited by law "unconstitutional" simply because that's where the authority fundamentally lies is not meaningful and is not what most people mean when they say "unconstitutional."
- btilly 13y agoYour point is wrong. Let's grab a random dictionary. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/unconstitutional http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/unconstitutional defines it as, not constitutional; unauthorized by or inconsistent with the constitution, as of a country. Note the "unauthorized by" bit, which is what we are discussing. Also go to the wikipedia links I gave you earlier for the two cases of note, and follow the various references in those links. You'll find "unconstitutional" being repeatedly used in the manner that I describe - and not as you claim it is used. In short if the courts rule that something is not allowed under the Constitution, people call it unconstitutional. And this applies whether their reasoning is that nothing authorizes the bill, or that the bill violates a specific protection in the Constitution.
- dllthomas 13y agoYou keep talking about something I am not talking about. "And this applies whether their reasoning is that nothing authorizes the bill, or that the bill violates a specific protection in the Constitution." But not that it simply happens to be prohibited by a law, where the constitution authorizes the law but doesn't require it. Not every violation of federal law is "unconstitutional", at least as commonly understood.
- btilly 13y agoD'oh, I scrolled back and you're right that I misread what mpayne had said. Indeed, something that is against a law that is constitutional is illegal, but not unconstitutional. It is only unconstitutional if you'd have to change the Constitution or (more often) the interpretation of the Constitution in order to make it be permitted.
- dllthomas 13y agoGood, yeah, I probably could've been clearer too... my brain isn't working as well today as it might.