6 ms·
But that argument then puts the whole program at a ridiculous cost to threat ratio. Sorry but this is just nonsense. Major terrorist acts e.g. 9/11 have a dev
by threeseed 13y ago
But that argument then puts the whole program at a ridiculous cost to threat ratio.
Sorry but this is just nonsense.
Major terrorist acts e.g. 9/11 have a devastating impact on the economy. It results in a country-wide drop in consumer spending, consumer confidence, business spending, business confidence, hiring etc. As well as locally in areas like tourism. It alone accounted for a 1.1% drop in the third quarter GDP in 2011.
As an example in NYC alone 430,000 jobs and 2.8 billion in wages were lost in the 3 months after 9/11. Which in turn results in a big drop in the tax collected.
Then finally there is the after effects. No 9/11 and there would have been no costly invasion into Iraq/Afghanistan which has cost trillions of dollars and an obscene number of lives. Major terrorist acts always demand a response by the public.
So out of all the things the government does protecting its citizens seems like something that will always be "worth the money".
- stretchwithme 13y agoThere are many threats to human life. There is a cost associated with preventing each life lost. Obviously it makes sense to consider it. We could have never allowed foreign tourists into the country. That has a cost associated with it, right? That would prevented Saudis from going to flight school and booking those flights, right? Shouldn't protecting lives be before every other consideration? No, we have to balance things. Protecting life can not prevent us from living our lives. Not everything the government chooses to do is worth the price.
- rayiner 13y agoIf we're going with a cost/benefit analysis, it should be noted that the NSA accessing data that AT&T, Google, Facebook, etc, already collect is just about the cheapest sort of counter-measure you could have to terrorism. The "good old fashioned police work" that people keep suggesting would be far more expensive and invasive.
- stretchwithme 13y agoThen let people volunteer for it in exchange for lower taxes. If the impact is truly minor, there should be many takers and much savings.
- rayiner 13y agoThat makes no sense.
- CamperBob2 13y agoWhat makes no sense is assuming that all of the data collection being discussed has prevented a single genuine attack.
- stretchwithme 13y agoOh, they told us it has. Shouldn't that be good enough? They've been open and honest so far.
- threeseed 13y agoAre you answering the right person ? Because I was specifically talking about the costs associated with terrorist acts. And that preventing them has significant and widespread benefits to the economy. It's pretty clear that focusing just on ROI alone this program is easily worth the price.
- stretchwithme 13y agoAnd just banning foreigners is free. The ROI is infinite on free things that work. But ROI is not the only consideration.
- mattnewton 13y agoWho says the cost is purely economic? What is the value of the first and fourth amendments to americans?
- mpyne 13y agoIntercepting messages doesn't violate the First Amendment. Intercepting messages with either "reasonable" means or "unreasonable means + probable cause warrant" also doesn't violate the Fourth Amendment. So I wouldn't necessarily make your sole complaint about the legality of the program, as it may very well soon be both legal and Constitutional.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago>Intercepting messages doesn't violate the First Amendment. What about all that stuff about chilling effects and anonymous speech?
- mpyne 13y agoYou mean like how the KKK and WBC were brutally subjugated by the U.S. government for their hateful speech? That kind of thing?
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoInvoking the KKK is the First Amendment equivalent of Godwin's Law. We let idiots have their stupid rallies because it's not the government's job to decide who gets to speak, and because the laws you would like to use against the KKK or WBC end up getting used against Malcolm X or Occupy protestors at a different time or in a different part of the country. And just to remind everyone, the reason we're worried about chilling effects and anonymous speech is that you don't want the first person to write anything challenging corrupt power structures to get indicted with "throw everything at the wall and see what sticks" charges backstopped by prolific surveillance, or have their house burned down by ideological opponents who use government powers to discover dissidents and are subsequently never prosecuted. Not only does that allow the injustice of corrupt power retaliating against activists for good, there is a real risk that the retaliation will be an effective deterrent to future activists.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- betterunix 13y ago"No 9/11 and there would have been no costly invasion into Iraq/Afghanistan which has cost trillions of dollars and an obscene number of lives" I have some doubts about us not going to war had there been no terrorist attack. Perhaps it would have been in a different country or continent, but there has been military action under every administration since Eisenhower. I have this sneaky suspicion that the war in Iraq would have happened regardless of any terrorist attack. I would even go as far as to say that the war in Iraq would have happened under a hypothetical Gore administration. "So out of all the things the government does protecting its citizens seems like something that will always be "worth the money"." Assuming, of course, that this program has accomplished anything. We are still waiting to see what details will be declassified. It is not enough that supporters of the program claim terrorist plots were stopped; we need to know (a) if the program was actually important to stopping those plots and (b) if those plots were realistic to begin with.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoThe economic numbers you're listing are pretty clearly dwarfed by the amount we've been spending on anti-terrorism. And nobody can take you seriously trying to shovel the excessive amount of money spent on anti-terrorism (or, as for Iraq, not on anti-terrorism) into the cost of a terrorist act and then trying to use that as justification for spending money on anti-terrorism. If we spent half the GDP on anti-terrorism after 9/11 you would be claiming 9/11 cost us half the GDP and that therefore justifies spending half the GDP on it. It's circular logic.
- gus_massa 13y agoAs far as I know, Iraq was not involved in the terrorist attack of 9/11. Why should the cost of the invasion into Iraq be consider in the damage caused by 9/11?
- saraid216 13y agoOn the other hand, 9/11 apparently resulted in a four-week drop in the UK suicide rate.
- CamperBob2 13y agoYou wouldn't happen to be in the market for a tiger-repelling rock, would you?
- D_Alex 13y ago>Major terrorist acts e.g. 9/11 have a devastating impact on the economy. Citation needed! 9/11 did indeed have a devastating impact on the economy - because of the very poorly thought out response of the Bush administration. On the other hand, Norway's response to their worst ever act of terrorism was as follows: Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg pledged to do everything to ensure the country's core values were not undermined. "The Norwegian response to violence is more democracy, more openness and greater political participation," he said. (from: http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120724/20363519819/one-year-after-breivik-massacre-norway-continues-to-fight-terrorism-with-democracy-openness-love.shtml http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120724/20363519819/one-ye... ) Do you think the US would be better off today if they adopted such a policy - instead of the Patriot Act?
- bdcravens 13y agoTo be fair, some of the post-9/11 policies did have an impact. However, don't discount the real effects the attack itself had, before the knee even had a chance to jerk. I was at Sabre (spin-off of American Airlines, owner of Travelocity, creator of travel agency software) at the time, in HR's development group. (Actually that group had been acquired by EDS, but same group, same role, different name on the paycheck) Within a trading day of the attack, they lost 50% in market cap. We went from massive projects to calculate performance based compensation to doing it on a simple spreadsheet. Many lost their jobs, including me.