6 ms·
OK, I've finally been motivated to go read the law itself. You can find it at http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1881a http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode
by btilly 13y ago
OK, I've finally been motivated to go read the law itself. You can find it at http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1881a http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1881a.
There are a lot of interesting things in there. For instance g.1.B allows wiretapping BEFORE they get the FISA rubber stamp. (But the warrant is still required to be sought. Whether this is done in practice is another question, but the warrant is still needed.)
However to me the single biggest red flag is g.4 which reads, A certification made under this subsection is not required to identify the specific facilities, places, premises, or property at which an acquisition authorized under subsection (a) will be directed or conducted.
Why is this interesting? Well compare with the 4th amendment, with the important bit highlighted by captitalization, The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, AND PARTICULARLY DESCRIBING THE PLACE TO BE SEARCHED, and the person or things to be seized.
How can anyone pretend that this law is constitutional???
- brown9-2 13y agoIs g.4 specific to an "acquisition" within the United States, or is it discussing authority to do so anywhere in the world?
- btilly 13y agoI do not know the answer to that.
- tptacek 13y agoYes. The FAA "Certification" scheme documented in this part of the law is like an SQL stored procedure. If NSA wants, instead of obtaining individualized authorizations from the FISC to surveil individual foreign targets, the DNI and Attorney General can together sign off on a "Certification" documenting the type of surveillance and the measures taken to ensure that such surveillance doesn't target Americans. The FISC reviews that Certification, and the NSA can reuse its structure multiple times by issuing "Directives".
- lemming 13y agoHow can anyone pretend that this law is constitutional??? It's easy. Just cover your ears with your hands, and then rock gently backwards and forwards and mutter under your breath: "the terrorists... the terrorists... the terrorists...". Recent studies have empirically shown that this will allow you to pretend whatever the hell you want.
- tptacek 13y agoBecause it regulates foreign surveillance, not domestic law enforcement. Similarly, the Army doesn't need to honor the 4th Amendment when in a combat theater abroad.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Joeri 13y agoSpeaking as a foreigner, I can assure you that "oh, this is only for foreigners" is not going over well in europe. I'm pretty sure the EU is going to come down hard on the US over this. Or rather, they will simply mandate that data for EU citizens is not allowed to leave the EU without the express prior consent of those citizens. It's the perfect excuse to give favorable treatment to the EU IT industry without the US having a legitimate complaint in front of the WTO.
- glurgh 13y agoThis seems highly unlikely given that just about every EU country engages in foreign surveillance. What do you think is the primary purpose of agencies such as the GHCQ or BND?
- marshray 13y agoAnd since there are intelligence-sharing agreements between the countries, countries are spying on their own citizens with deniability by doing it through third parties. If they even care enough to maintain the ruse. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes
- munin 13y agowhat you say is false, EO12333 expressly forbids this with the following: "2.12 Indirect Participation. No element of the Intelligence Community shall participate in or request any person to undertake activities forbidden by this Order. "
- rayiner 13y ago> How can anyone pretend that this law is constitutional??? The whole premise of FISA was to add an additional layer of protections in situations where no Article III warrant was necessary in the first place. Before FISA, to the extent that the target had no 4th amendment rights (foreign intelligence agent) or the monitoring in question was not a "search", then the government could do whatever the hell it wanted. FISA created an additional layer where the government had to get a FISA warrant to engage in that activity. Because the 4th amendment wasn't implicated, it was unnecessary for FISA warrants to meet the particularity requirements of Article III warrants. The argument, thus, is "what is a search?" Is collecting AT&T's call data records a "search" that requires a Article III warrant? If not, then a "give us everything" FISA warrant is not unconstitutional. I imagine that's the interpretation the NSA is operating on.
- btilly 13y agoThe problem is that the 4th has not, in my opinion, been satisfied. I'm not happy with all of my data being sucked into a database which is a very tempting target. The administration does not think this violates the 4th, I think it does. But even if we grant their theory that it does not violate the 4th, there is no question that searches have been conducted under any definition of the term that can and do accidentally sweep up Americans. Proving that it happened to you, individually, is very hard. But it happens. The 4th is violated. And once it is, we're dependent upon the good will and honesty of the government to forget what they saw that they were not supposed to do so. The standard which I want to see for all parts of the Constitution - including the 4th - is that the burden of proof is on the government to guarantee that no wrong is done. That, in another context, is the whole point of habeas corpus. The same standard should be applied here. As a US citizen who grew up in another country, 50.1% confidence does not comfort me. As a person who has seen people with privileged information who were not supposed to leak it leak it in lots of other contexts, I have little trust that government spooks are going to be better. (In one example, a stalker bribed the CA DMV to find the address of the car owned by a woman I know.) As a person who has seen databases abused, I know how easy that is to do once you've centralized data. (One amusing example involved a woman who worked in a bank who did a search for all single men in a particular age range with incomes over a certain threshold in a particular geographic area...) And once you've centralized the data, I think it is just a question of time until bad actors manage to get their hands on copies of it all. Yes, I know that the people who are doing this are convinced that they are saving the world. But in the long run, their actions scare me more than the terrorists that they claim to be protecting me from.
- anigbrowl 13y agoFISA = Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The 'right of the people' in the 4th amendment is the right of the American people (ie citizens of the USA). You only read part of the law, that is, statute. Court precedent is law too, and not looking up cases where the statute in question has been at issue means you have only partially informed yourself. The US has a common law legal system, not a civil one.