4 ms·
While I applaud the effort, in the end, it is mostly just a game played by lawyers who write ToS. Terms of Service tries to be legally document, enforceable ac
by belorn 13y ago
While I applaud the effort, in the end, it is mostly just a game played by lawyers who write ToS.
Terms of Service tries to be legally document, enforceable across borders. Its not related to copyright, so there aren't any treaties to unify each countries laws. Also, because it is not copyright, ToS get put into the all covering service/contract law. Where I live, Sweden, those laws was written in 1900, and is in my view 100% incompatible with ToS or EULA's.
To take one example, they require that the person providing a contract makes sure that the other party is fully informed of the contract, and that the other party is benefited from signing the contract in relation to the terms. Reading the history around it, they basically makes in unlawful to knowingly "trick" people to sign contracts that are one-sided.[1]
On the "trick people to sign" part, I am also slightly considering the fact that companies often know how long time someone spends reading an ToS/EULA. They know when, and how many people can't have human possible read the agreement before pressing OK. When MMORPG clients update a new agreement, people are logging in seconds after its possible. If you knowingly are going into a contract with someone who hasn't read and understood the terms, its hard to claim that the contract was made in good-faith (jfr BrB 9 kap 1 §).
All in all, ToS and EULA's just seems to me as an broken concept.
https://lagen.nu/1915:218 https://lagen.nu/1915:218 30§ and 36§
- jancborchardt 13y agoWe pretty much agree that it’s a broken concept. But that doesn’t keep companies from data retention, or using your content with their copyright, or or or …
- seferphier 13y agoI believe the purpose of service is to raise awareness of your legal rights and what rights you sacrifice when using the service. In Common Law jurisdictions, "I read and agree with ToS" is prima facie (on its surface) binding on the user. You cannot get away from a contract by simply not reading it - many people would repudiate their contracts if this was the case. I do not believe there is such a law in Common Law about "tricking people" to sign contracts. Whether a term is lawful depends on the circumstances of the case - this is why law is complex and must be cases must be litigated in order to determine lawfulness. Many contracts we sign are one-sided. This is due to the respected bargaining power of the parties. The courts and the legislature have to balance between interfering with the freedom of contract and the notion of fairness. Some terms must be one-sided by nature- eg: banks can unilaterally change the interest rate on your property.
- belorn 13y agoSince QoS/ToS is a primarly unenforceable contract meant for a global market, a service that points out the different kinds of unenforceable contracts is a praiseworthy service, but with somewhat limited use. >You cannot get away from a contract by simply not reading it Well, in Swedish law, quite a lot weight is given to the circumstances around the contract, and if it was made in good faith. Take people who sends out false bills, relying on people who do not read the letter fully and see that it actually was not a bill but an "offer of service". That is still fraud, and people who pay those bills without reading it can still get away from the "contract". This might be different in UK, Germany, any of the state laws in US and so on. Maybe some of the 27,000 pages of federal law has something about it, but I am not a US lawyer. The laws are so old that what exactly can nullify a contract in one country will likely be different from an other. > The courts and the legislature have to balance between interfering with the freedom of contract and the notion of fairness. This is an area where laws are likely to be very different between countries. It touches on consumer protection, as well as contract law. The Swedish law is very unspecific here, and just generically defines that unjust terms are grounds enough to nullify a contract either in parts or in full. The consumer protection laws goes a bit further, and declares that the party offering a service must make sure that the consumer is fully informed about the terms, and must also make sure that the consumer is benefited from agreeing to the contracts and all its terms. If not, then the consumer has a right to nullify the contract and get back any money already paid. For the bank example, this mean that the bank must make sure the consumer is aware of the costs involved before signing, and the the rates are within reasonable levels. If they tried to get someone to agree to a 1000% interest loan, the contract would be almost guaranteed to be nullified in court if challenged.
- seferphier 13y agoYeah, I am talking about Common Law in general. Interestingly, consumer protection aspect you talk about is very similar. Stronger protection is given to consumers through legislation - eg: Sales of Goods Act in UK. The word "reasonable" is ingrained into common law and a 1000% interest loan would certainly not be reasonable. >You cannot get away from a contract by simply not reading it All circumstances around the contract would be considered in common law. I believe the courts would rather void the term on the basis of unfairness rather than putting weight on the fact that the person did not read it. Contract is binding even if you have not read the contract is a very important cornerstone of contract law. Almost everyone that signs the contract does not read the contract - even contract that exceeds billions of dollars. They turn to their lawyers to read and negotiate the terms. Complex and specific terms are required to specify the rights and obligation of each side. If we are forced to read the contract before we sign them, our society would not be able to operate and many disputes would arise over overly broad terms that can be interpreted in many different ways.