6 ms·
The business case for serving web content isn't as strong as you might think from a back of the envelope calculation about cost/power vs. performance. It's true
by luu 13y ago
The business case for serving web content isn't as strong as you might think from a back of the envelope calculation about cost/power vs. performance. It's true that you'll find that you can get more throughput per cost with ARM/Atom (mostly due to the lower power, but also because the machines are cheaper), but, when you actually do it you'll find that latency is significantly higher, if you compare ARM/Atom boxes with low load vs. fast x86 machines with high utilization [1]. An argument people often make is that ARM is going to catch x86. Sure, possibly, but why wouldn't you expect x86 to catch ARM? [2]
A lesson that people seem to have to keep re-learning, over and over again, is that latency matters a lot on the web. A few ms increase in latency has a measurable effect on your income, as people just close the webpage and click elsewhere. A significant increase in latency is disastrous.
[1] http://users.ece.utexas.edu/~vjreddi/UT/Publications/Entries/2011/8/1_Mobile_Processors_for_Energy-Efficient_Web_Search,_In__i_IEEE_Transactions_on_Computer_Systems_(TOCS)__i_,_Vol._29,_No._4,_Article_9,_August_2011._files/reddi2011-tocs.pdf http://users.ece.utexas.edu/~vjreddi/UT/Publications/Entries.... This paper describes a way you can use low-power boxes to get better results for the same cost, but it doesn't involve simply swapping your core i5s with Atoms or ARMs, which is what a lot of people seem to want to do.
[2] One of the major lessons computer architects learned perhaps 10-15 years ago is that the instruction set just doesn't matter that much, compared to the microarchitecture, the manufacturing process, and the quality of the circuit design. Intel has a decisive advantage in manufacturing that's been growing for approximately two decades, ARM doesn't even try to compete in circuit design with full-custom design or fancy circuit techniques, so that leaves the microarchitecture. Although I'd disagree, you might make a case that ARM simply has better architects, and that ARM would produce a better design than Intel if they targeted the exact same space. But, I doubt you'd try to make the case that you'd expect ARM's design to be so superior that it will obviously overcome Intel's other advantages.
Another case you might make is that Intel simply won't target the same space, to avoid cannibalizing their own market, but, in addition to obviously moving towards that space with Atom, they have a history of ruthlessness that makes that seem unlikely.
Intel used to be a dominant player in the DRAM industry, but they killed off their DRAM business when they were a leader in the field, because they recognized that it would become a commodity industry. After becoming a market leader in SRAMs, one of the competitors invented flash; they realized the significance and focused on flash and microprocessors, while, again, killing off what was (then) a major cash cow. It's very hard to imagine Intel just sitting and slowly losing their dominance of the microprocessor industry, ending up with a position like IBM or Sun. They've never done that in the past, so why would you expect them to start now?
- akiselev 13y agoJust to second this point, most people just have no conception of what semiconductor manufacturing is like and this article seems especially misinformed about the manufacturing side. For example: "The ARM collective simply show up to Samsung or TWSC, or TI or Global Foundries, ask for a zillion processors to run off the manufacturing lines and wonder if they can have them by Tuesday?" which is just total bullshit. The reason Apple had to buy so many processors from Samsung for so long is because setting up a new processor is expensive and difficult, whether it's an Intel or Global Foundries and it sure as hell doesn't take less than six months, let alone a week before you can get a reliable shipment of chips for a consumer product. (and before you can talk about volume of ARM vs Intel, compare the dozen+ companies that can manufacture 24-60-something nm to the ONE company that can do 22 and lower: Intel) There are many competitors in the semiconductor manufacturing space because COMBINED they don't have the manufacturing or scientific resources of Intel (TI and Qualcomm have massive R&D arms but they're more concerned with wireless and other electronics). Intel's first mass market 14 nm facility is supposed to go live this year and Samsung just BARELY got their 14nm demo out this year. Intel's plant was $5 billion and started in 2011 which means that Intel has years to improve their power, bus speeds, and reliability before any manufacturer will even be able to sell their first processor. As the technology nears sub-10nm, the gaps between performance and power consumption between the architectures will be more and more obvious. All of the other semifab manufacturers are extremely reliant on third party suppliers for their factories whereas Intel helped develop a huge portion of their technology, many times outright owning part of the equipment manufacturers (for example, http://www.extremetech.com/computing/132604-intel-invests-in-asml-to-boost-extreme-uv-lithography-massive-450mm-wafers http://www.extremetech.com/computing/132604-intel-invests-in...). 14nm was the point where they hit a lot of physical phenomena that prevent e-beam lithography and some of the other methods from working and Intel's pretty much the only one that can really push this technology forward. Edit: Also, http://www.tomshardware.com/news/intel-cpu-processor-5nm,17578.html http://www.tomshardware.com/news/intel-cpu-processor-5nm,175... - it's over. Notice how Intel said they're going to push their SoC's to their current processes? Hopefully this means that in 2015 we'll have 10nm x86 SoCs (at which point ARM will be, best case scenario, nearing end-of-life 22nm)
- ricw 13y ago