3 ms·
> There is no such thing as security without a tradeoff The original implementation of Skype was convenient and secure.
by Zigurd 13y ago
> There is no such thing as security without a tradeoff
The original implementation of Skype was convenient and secure.
- venus 13y agoWell, that traded off the govt's ability to wiretap.
- Zigurd 13y agoWouldn't every system based on strong encryption prevent wiretaps? The only way to do that and preserve the power to wiretap is to make open source encryption illegal and mandate the use of key escrow. That would be hard to enforce. It appears that neither the developers of Skype nor the government of Estonia viewed that as a bad trade-off.
- venus 13y agoI wasn't trying to make some kind of statement with my comment - I was merely pointing out an identifiable trade-off. That said, if and when an easy-to-use, truly secure p2p communication system ever gains real traction then action against it will probably be on the table. Banning won't really work, as you say, but it can probably be made inconvenient/unpalatable enough to discourage most users. I think most people agree that there do exist legitimate cases for governmental wiretapping, as long as the rules are agreed upon and followed strictly. Genuine untappable comms will be a threat to that legitimate government function and I don't think, barring some radical shift in popular opinion, there will be much opposition to such a ban.
- gnosis 13y agoConventional encryption (strong or otherwise) does absolutely nothing to prevent wiretaps. If the encryption algorithm that's used is well respected among cryptographers and has no known, practically exploitable weaknesses; if this algorithm has been implemented correctly in the encryption software; if the software is used properly by every party involved in the communcation; if these parties' systems have not been compromised; if the people or entitites interested in your communication are not (like the NSA is speculated to be) 20 to 30 years ahead of the public cryptography community -- all very big if's -- then you might buy yourself some time until the encryption is finally broken (something that might happen tomorrow, or next month, or next year, or 20 years from now, or never, who knows?). In the meantime, your encrypted communication could be intercepted, recorded, and stored indefinitely -- and available for a practically limitless number of decryption attempts in the future.
- gnosis 13y agoSkype was "secure", for some limited definition of the term. It was secure if you trust a closed-source program made by a company that could be decrypting your communication because they've got your keys, or that could have put any number of backdoors in the program. And it's secure if you don't consider the possibility of doing traffic analysis, or the fact that most people are identifiable by their IP addresses, etc. If you lower your standards enough, I guess anything could be considered "secure".
- Zigurd 13y agoStarting with closed-source clients, yeah, Skype had limitations w.r.t security and trust. OTOH, I don't recall a successful attack on Skype. My comment was more directed toward the fact that ephemeral keys and P2P can be secure and convenient for real-time communication.
- danso 13y agoHowever, the trade off is that whoever you want to communicate with has to have that same client (Skype or anything)...no big deal, you say? just have everyone use it?...well, once a service gets that much penetration, a company will own the popular implementation, and then you're back to square one.