3 ms·
Feudal lords subjugated the many through threats of violence, not "economic bonds". "Economic bonds" is just another term for "made the best offer" - that's ver
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Feudal lords subjugated the many through threats of violence, not "economic bonds". "Economic bonds" is just another term for "made the best offer" - that's very far from what feudal lords did.
- pron 13y agoIt was through economic bonds. Not to get into too much detail, but the lower ranks of feudal nobility were "lords of manors" (with higher ranks being lords of lords). The manor system (manorialism[1]) was the economic foundation of feudal society. Back when I studied history (many years ago), I read one the most fascinating history papers I've ever read: The Rise of Dependent Cultivation and Seignorial Institutions by Marc Bloch[2] (I couldn't find a free version online). There was little, if any, violence directed at peasants - certainly not one meant to get them to work. The entire system was founded on the fact that peasants had little choice: they didn't own the land, and it was hard for them to relocate to other manors. Systems built around direct coercion, with the threat of violence, are rarely stable. Successful exploitation is one whose targets either hardly feel or one that's not bad enough to get them to rebel. The way these systems often collapse is that over time, the exploiters feel more confident to exploit even more, until they reach a breaking point at which a rebellion occurs. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manorialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manorialism [2]: http://universitypublishingonline.org/cambridge/histories/chapter.jsf?bid=CBO9781139054423&cid=CBO9781139054423A009 http://universitypublishingonline.org/cambridge/histories/ch...
- mjn 13y agoIt does vary based on the region/era we're talking about. The Russian system of serfdom was much more formalized, closer to a form of slavery, where serfs were owned by their estates. But you're right that in many other regions/periods, peasants were formally free, and legally able to live anywhere they wanted, as long as they reached an arrangement with the landowner (otherwise, of course, it would be trespassing). Since the land was all owned by a smallish number of landowners, the only way to make a living if you were not one of them was to work someone else's land, on terms largely dictated by them, so economics effectively tied peasants to the manorial lord. I'll see if I can dig up the source, but I read an interesting analysis specifically of the transition to feudalism in late-Roman Italy. As the pax Romana weakened, the city of Rome was increasingly unable to be kept supplied with food imported through smoothly functioning trade routes (especially grain from North Africa), so much of the population fled the city for the countryside. There, they had little choice but to reach generally unfavorable agreements with estate owners for permission to work on their land, since Italy was already too densely populated for American-style frontier homesteading in unclaimed land to be possible.