3 ms·
Honestly though, why increase height and density still further? There are stupendous issues here with efficiency with regards to food, water, and HVAC - if noth
by btilly 13y ago
Honestly though, why increase height and density still further? There are stupendous issues here with efficiency with regards to food, water, and HVAC - if nothing else.
Can you back up your impression that there are stupendous efficiency issues with numbers?
In the USA multiple studies have been done on the question. They find that the per capita carbon footprint of people living in major metropolitan areas is lower than those living in smaller cities and the country. And NYC, that concrete jungle that epitomizes a disconnect from anything natural, is actually per capita the one of the 10 most ecologically friendly cities in the nation!
It may be unbelievable to you that it is environmentally friendly to pack people densely enough that walking and public transit become favored options. So I point you to http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/reports/2008/5/carbon%20footprint%20sarzynski/carbonfootprint_brief http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/reports/2008... for a citation.
- contingencies 13y agoCan you back up your impression that there are stupendous efficiency issues with numbers? I would have thought that the cost of hauling food and water up 60 floors was self-evident? While I could go invest time finding numbers, to be honest I find it a bit rich that you ask me to provide sources while making equally unreferenced, sweeping and IMHO dicier claims in response. For example, claiming the carbon footprint of city dwellers is low might be possible if it doesn't consider the cost of hauling the products they routinely use and throw away at rates far higher than other people on the planet... but that doesn't make it a realistic or truthful stance on the matter. I am not surprised that NYC is low on obvious evils when considering this form of skin-deep environmental statistic, because it produces very little of... well, anything. As the center of finance, NY derives a great amount of wealth from achieving effectively zero of utility to the rest of the world. For something more concrete, let's try measuring garbage. (I'm not going to get in to the interesting question of Wall St.'s facilitatory role in greater evils.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_issues_in_New_York_City#Garbage_disposal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_issues_in_New_Yo... In September 2012, Travel+Leisure named New York City the #1 "America's Dirtiest City," from the results of a readership survey rating 35 "Favorite Cities" in the United States. It continues: In 2006 Mayor Michael Bloomberg signed legislation establishing a new solid waste management plan, which will use barges and trains to export 90% of the city’s 12,000 daily tons of residential trash. I can tell you that country people don't generate that much trash, and they can often dispose of it in a decentralized fashion (eg. via compost). Even Mexico City only produces 10,000 tons per day (random stat online), and its population is far higher and they probably actually make some tangible goods. But I'm not going to go build a well-referenced numerology of truth here. I hope you might be motivated to research further yourself. The bottom line is that nature loves decentralization, and 'taxes' centralization. Cities are unnatural conglomerations that abhor nature. While we can sustain them, it's not the smartest thing to do in a finite world. Society is just beginning to learn from and invest in this with concessions to green architecture, urban design, public transportation, public communications infrastructure projects (Australia, China, France, New Zealand...), decentralized energy generation, etc.
- tekacs 13y agoUp 60 floors perhaps, but getting it there required only bringing it a few miles from the nearest depot (having been brought there en-masse) rather than a giant star (or worse) network, replicating the same effort 1000 times to transport said food and commodities and to provide infrastructure to every one of the many parties in the decentralised model you propose as more efficient. :/
- btilly 13y agoPoint of obvious fact for you. When I provide a citation, that's not an unreferenced claim. And, unlike you, I'm not cherry picking my references. What do I mean by cherry picking? Let's take your Wikipedia link, one sentence before the travel and leisure survey. New York City accounts for only 1% of United States greenhouse gas emissions while housing 2.7% of its population. This is all consistent with what I said. NYC has a ton of people. Having a ton of people, it is inevitably an environmental eyesore. However, per person, it is environmentally better than the alternative. Let's look at your garbage claim. NYC produces 12,000 tons per day of garbage. NYC has about 8.3 million people. That's 2.89 pounds of garbage per person. From http://www.cleanair.org/Waste/wasteFacts.html http://www.cleanair.org/Waste/wasteFacts.html we see that the average American produces 4.5 pounds of garbage per day, of which 66.8% is sent to landfill. That's 3.01 pounds. Again, per capita, NYC beats the rest of the USA. Of course this is slightly unfair. Again, as you note, NYC has mostly outsourced its manufacturing. Manufacturing generates lots of garbage. I don't see an easy way to quantify that. However I do note that NYC has a high density of very rich people whose consumption can be expected to be above average. I've lived in the country. Based on my experience, people who live in the country create tons of garbage, it is just not centralized. It is true that Mexico city does better. However Mexico city is also poorer. Poor people, out of necessity, cannot consume much. Next let's move on to your points about raising water. First of all, as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyscraper#Environmental_impact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyscraper#Environmental_impac... makes clear, it is true that it takes energy to put stuff high in the sky. But there are tradeoffs and it is not at all clear whether a skyscraper is or is not environmentally efficient. But that's irrelevant. The population density of NYC doesn't require high skyscrapers. I've lived there. It is really dependent upon having small apartments, packed closely together. Most of the city is made up of buildings that are 5 stories high. (Because at 6 stories you need to install elevators.) As for your general hate of cities, I submit that the facts don't support it. It is true that cities are unnatural, expensive things. However, per capita, they tend be more efficient. But fundamentally there is no way to support an unlimited number of people in a finite world.