3 ms·
Imagine if you were designing a system to store massive amounts of intercepted email data for archival and occasional retrieval. The design would be quite diff
by grandalf 13y ago
Imagine if you were designing a system to store massive amounts of intercepted email data for archival and occasional retrieval. The design would be quite different from gmail and it would require a lot less infrastructure.
I think your analysis is perhaps being biased a bit by the idea that dealing with all the email data would be massively expensive.
Also, consider that phone companies already have existing government granted monopolies, while companies like Google and Facebook are significantly more vulnerable to bad press or some kind of disruption triggered by public mistrust.
Hence one possible strategy for minimizing the impact of Snowden's revelations would be to admit to the phone aspect of the powerpoint and to drastically minimize the relationships with web companies.
Also considering the power of ad network cookies and the amount of information stored, the intelligence value of internet companies' data dwarfs the value of phone call data by several orders of magnitude.
- tptacek 13y agoYou think the average American would be less concerned about direct access to Google Mail than they would about the NSA having the ability to listen to everyone's phone calls?
- grandalf 13y agoI think the opposite, which is why I think the story is evolving to minimize the gmail access being done.
- mpyne 13y agoPerhaps it's evolving closer to what the truth actually was the whole time?
- grandalf 13y agoThat is possible, though what we're seeing is the result of the PR response of the NSA taking effect. The NSA does not have any incentive for the truth to be revealed, only for the public to stop worrying about it.