3 ms·
Ummm, this is as reported by CBS as reported by whomever they hired to do the forensic analysis. And yes, if "the NSA" were to break in it's possible they migh
by hga 13y ago
Ummm, this is as reported by CBS as reported by whomever they hired to do the forensic analysis.
And yes, if "the NSA" were to break in it's possible they might not be able to do it tracelessly. E.g. no one as of yet is suspecting a black bag job.
- tptacek 13y agoWe are thus far discussing technical details of an attack that would be easy for a teenager to have carried out in 1999, let alone 2013, and are attributing them to the world's most experienced computer security organization. I think that's happening because it's much more fun to think about NSA breaking into media laptops than it is to think about random Eastern European hackers doing the same, and HN has a profound bias towards whichever narrative is more fun to talk about.
- mrschwabe 13y agoMaybe its 'fun' to talk about or maybe it's just the first logical assumption given the circumstances. Have you read the news man? Everybody should have a bias to blaming the NSA for breaking into journalist laptops! Geez, they have motives and the means.
- tptacek 13y agoThis is pure innuendo.
- ben1040 13y agoYep. It seems logical that an high profile reporter might be a target for other potential attackers who are not the NSA. Even if it's just some smart teenager somewhere, doing it "for the lulz" to say they got someone of that level. I can also imagine that an investigative journalist, whose livelihood is made in part based upon tips received from people external to the newsroom, might easily become a target for a spear phishing attack from any of those potential actors. But to immediately attribute this to the NSA strictly based on the facts laid down in this article, that seems like making a heavy use of a Jump to Conclusions Mat.
- hga 13y agoYou maybe positing that this could be the NSA; me, I hope they're not quite that corrupt as of yet. I'm assuming other state actors (the DoJ currently is saying "Not to our knowledge"), or someone attacking for political motives but not a formal state actor.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm the opposite of believing someone working for the USG hacked into a reporter's laptop. I believe "someone attacking for political motives but not a formal state actor" is the second most likely scenario, after "laptop was randomly popped by a drive-by Java or Flash vulnerability and WaPo wants it to be more newsworthy than it is". I sound cynical about news organizations here, but I'm not. I just think they suck at reporting on computer security stories.
- hga 13y agoWhy do you keep harping on the WaPo? She's a CBS reporter, CBS is reporting this analysis, and they're the ones who hired whomever did the forensic analysis. Here it is from the horse's mouth: http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-201_162-57589367/cbs-news-confirms-sharyl-attkissons-computer-hacked/ http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-201_162-57589367/cbs-news-confir...
- tptacek 13y agoWe're commenting on a WaPo story, is why. But sure; in case it matters, s/WaPo/CBS/g and I stand by the same set of arguments.
- Nrsolis 13y agoJust because it doesn't look like the job of the most likely agency of the USG to do doesn't mean that it wasn't some other part of the USG that did it. The oversight and internal motivations of the USG (indeed, any government) aren't uniform. Not by a long shot. Case in point: JSOC developed their own intelligence capability that was a rival to that of the CIA and used it for their own purposes. That was one of the things that the DoD did that seems to replicate a capability available elsewhere in the USG and almost entirely for the purpose of escaping oversight. BTW, Jeremy Scahill (author of Blackwater and Dirty Wars) reported that HIS laptop was hacked. When you combine this with the surveillance of AP reporters and it does seem that certain parts of the USG seem to feel that journalists are worthy and legitimate intelligence targets.
- mrschwabe 13y agoExactly! And to compliment your second point; in light of the biggest intelligence leak in history just last week - at the hands of just one frustrated sysadmin; it illustrates just how inept these agencies can be.
- tptacek 13y agoNSA's attack/penetration teams are not inept.