4 ms·
Greenwald was talking to him since January or February. So yeah, I think he had time to prepare what he'd say in front of a camera for a few minutes in this his
by mtgx 13y ago
Greenwald was talking to him since January or February. So yeah, I think he had time to prepare what he'd say in front of a camera for a few minutes in this historic moment...Wouldn't you do the same? Or would you rather sound like a blabbering idiot?
- cwisecarver 13y agoHe worked for Booz-Allen for three months. June - Three = March. So ... Greenwald and him were just chatting about the weather for a month or two?
- waterlesscloud 13y agoHe had worked for other intel contractors prior to that, quite possibly in exactly the same job.
- brown9-2 13y agoThis is one curious bit of the story that I am surprised other journalists haven't yet harped on Greenwald to reveal. For instance, did GG know if Snowden planned to take the BAH job for the purposes of taking documents?
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoIs it known that the source of the docs is exclusively from BAH? I'm not convinced you can get such attention from a high profile journalist simply by claiming that you have Top Secret access and that you plan to leak some documents to him.
- brown9-2 13y agoWhat high-profile journalist would ignore a chance to look at or publish Top Secret documents?
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoCall one on the phone and ask him to meet you in Hong Kong.
- tome 13y agoSo the NSA is this organisation which can tell what you are saying to anyone else, yet it failed to realise that Snowden was talking to Greenwald for about six months?
- liljimmytables 13y agothe fact that the NSA routinely monitors certain channels does not turn them into an omniscient boogieman that can read everybody's minds. in fact, being aware of the channels that they monitor puts you in an excellent position in this respect
- etherael 13y agoI read about him asking Greenwald to setup PGP some time ago and him not actually communicating with him until that happened. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/10/edward-snowden-glenn-greenwald_n_3416978.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/10/edward-snowden-glen... So, reading between the lines, PGP is safe, but that's hardly headline news.
- jebeng 13y agoJust want to chime in and say that this doesn't imply that PGP is safe. I mean, it probably is. They would not let us know, either way.
- alex_doom 13y agoIt's going to be missed by passive data sweeps. If someone had suspected and was watching him that's a different story.
- vidarh 13y agoCrypto is "safe enough" based on an idea of how long the data needs to be protected. Best case it is "safe" for the time it will take to brute force the entire key space, but in reality most crypto will remain safe much shorter than that. We've increased typical keysizes for PGP many times over the years because we expect there's a reasonable change for smaller keys to be broken too quickly. In other words: You should not infer that PGP is "safe", but that he believed PGP with the key size he used would protect the messages until it doesn't matter if they're revealed at least from the level of monitoring he feared, which could just mean safe against routine intercepts and security scans for the few months until his identity was revealed anyway.
- bpatrianakos 13y agoBut there's more to it than that and I for one am glad someone expressed their doubts while everyone else seems to be taking the facts we have and either believing them totally or speculating to the point where its an exercise in spreading FUD. I don't doubt the authenticity of the leaks and I don't doubt Snowden saw abuses of power. My question is, is this really big news? I remember hearing about it in 2006 and since then I thought we all knew the government was vacuuming up phone and Internet data like it was going out of style. This leak is more confirmation of what we already knew with a few new surprises sprinkled in, but nothing that could overshadow the big problem which was that the government is intercepting about all communications within the US. What I doubt are some of Snowden's motivations and the amount of information and power he really has. He addresses the question of why he chose to not be anonymous by dancing around the question with some hand wavy answer that just about translates to "because I'm gonna be a patriot and/or a hero". He calls a lot of attention to himself very unnecessarily too. It's almost like there's a part of him that wants to feel important. Another thing that doesn't fit the narrative around this story is Snowden's role before he became a whistleblower. We're very quick to jump on the idea that the US government is this incredibly powerful, nefarious organization that's been competent enough to conduct a truly massive global and domestic secret spy program for 8 to 15 years depending on your sources. If that's the case, how do you let individuals like Snowden, with what we know about him so far (he's a young high school dropout hopping from job to job somewhat frequently, working for a contractor, who even describes himself as no one special with no special skills - ie an "Everyman") have as much power and access as he claims to have? If you're trying to keep a secret you make damn sure to compartmentalize the hell out of your organization so that no one person can see the big picture without having to go on a wild goose chase to put all the pieces together. Hell, even I don't have access to things you'd think I should have access to at my job and there's not a damn thing secret about it. There's no defending the NSA though. What's happening is wrong and there's no gray area there. However, I don't think Snowden can be any help to anyone anymore beyond simply getting attention and having something to talk about in the absence of any other concrete facts. I see Snowden as the guy who brought up an issue we should have never let go back when it first came out and because of that I'm glad he came forward. Other than that, I think he overstates his role and maybe even some of the particulars relating to this spy program.