4 ms·
This is a general trend you can see at work in lots of venture-connected industries, and it's not just about surveillance. Lots of people take gigs working on
by kevingadd 13y ago
This is a general trend you can see at work in lots of venture-connected industries, and it's not just about surveillance.
Lots of people take gigs working on 'cool', 'interesting', terrifyingly profitable projects at well-funded, fast-growing startups that the press and investors both love. It looks great on their resume, they get to tell their friends about the cool work they're doing, and they learn lots of new stuff. Great, right?
Of course, on the other hand, lots of these startups are directly preying on the uninformed, the mentally ill, and groups that simply can't make good decisions, like the young. Over time eventually controls and safeguards get added to reduce the damage done, stop those 'top customers' from paying TOO MUCH, and staunch the blood loss from horrible churn and counteract the consequences of short-term focused designs. Ideally, by the time these fixes start happening and consequences start destroying revenue, these startups have IPOd or exited and the founders and investors all exit happy and wealthy to move onto the next gig.
Here's the thing - that whole last paragraph was describing games startups, not the obvious evil of surveillance companies. It's almost like we gleefully allow ourselves to be blinded to the consequences, both short-term and long-term, of our actions, and pretend that whatever we're working on is innocent and harmless, just because it isn't directly selling rifles to terrorists. It's easier not to think through the consequences; to think about where our money is coming from, to think about who's buying our products, to think about what using our products does to people's lives, and to their relationships. To think about what those viral acquisition pathways do in the long term, to think about what those retention and churn metrics really mean, to think about WHY those metrics are going up or down. Most people don't think about what the unanticipated consequences could be from storing users' address books, or their call histories, or leaving a camera/microphone on all time, or automatically logging conversations. It's easy not to do those things.
Because at the end of the day, the person with the clean conscience doesn't have 50 million dollars, and if you somehow come face-to-face with the consequences of your actions, well... lawyers don't cost that much, do they?
It's easy to look at the whole venture-funded startup industry and find the big picture kind of exhausting when viewed with this perspective. Most of the people starting these companies, and working at these companies - they're not objectively bad people! Their actions, in a short-term context, are wholly defensible - there's no reason to question them. But somehow we keep ending up in this situation, and we're looking back, and saying, jeez, that sure hurt a lot of people, didn't it? Or wow, how did they do something that stupid? Why did anyone invest in them? Why was anyone stupid enough to go work at that company that did those awful things?
- lesedilino 13y agoAaron Swartz looked back at reddit. He realized the company that made him rich was now nothing but a mechanism to create addictions to meme-bytes, waste time, destroy relationships, normalize sexism and racism, and literally rekindle the Neo-Nazi movement (reddit now has the biggest concentration of Neo-Nazis on the internet--the fanatical kind that even Stormfront won't tolerate on their website). If this is even the fate for something as benign as reddit, how much worse will it turn out for people working in Big Data or directly on technologies like facial recognition? How many Silicon Valley technologists will look back at their work in 50 years and have the same kind of feeling that Nazi scientists had, that Manhatten Project physicists had, that the inventors of mustard gas had? Whether technology will be used as a weapon in the hands of a selfish elite, or as a tool for liberation for the impoverished and underprivileged, is being decided now by how these technologists use their time.
- CamperBob2 13y agoYes, when you create a venue for free speech, it will -- gasp -- be used to express various opinions and ideas you will not agree with. So? The Nazis had no trouble doing their dirty work the last time without Facebook, Reddit, or Twitter. These days, they have more to lose from exposure than they would ever have to gain. The antidote to bad speech is more speech, and that's precisely what Reddit is good for.
- lesedilino 13y agoIn sane countries hate speech is criminalized. History does not support your naive view that allowing criminals to freely congregate, organize, and recruit stops their ideology. The Neo-Nazis on reddit have publicized the tactics they're using to normalize racism across the internet. According to watchdog groups the Neo-Nazi movement has grown tremendously since it was able to start recruiting and spreading that hate ideology online.
- CamperBob2 13y ago(Shrug) Who cares? Talk is cheap, even for Nazis. Take your Orwellian worldview and peddle it somewhere else. Our history books evidently say very different things.