6 ms·
As a hardcore techie, software developer and tech entrepreneur, you would think that I'd be lining up to support the Pirate Party. But, alas, other than cyber-s
by mindcrime 13y ago
As a hardcore techie, software developer and tech entrepreneur, you would think that I'd be lining up to support the Pirate Party. But, alas, other than cyber-security and digital rights issues, I don't necessarily agree with them about anything else. I also don't necessarily disagree but since they don't appear to have much a published platform and planks, it's hard to say. But I've seen some Pirates describe them as a "progressive" party, and I'm pretty skeptical of "progressives" and their policy positions. Anyway, for my money, it's the Libertarian Party that represents the path forward, not the Pirate Party.
Unfortunately, the problem in the US isn't that we don't have enough parties. We have tons of political parties in the US, ranging from the Libertarian Party, to the Green Party, to the Pirate Party, to the Worker's World Party, to the Prohibition Party, to the Modern Whig Party. No, the problem is plurality / first-past-the-post voting. As Duverger's Law notes, a plurality / FPTP voting system almost always results in a two party dominated system (like we have).
Switch voting to Approval Voting, Range Voting, or a Condorcet method, and we might see some meaningful change.
- flyinRyan 13y agoThe fact that the "libertarian party" is a "thing" in the US is a large sign of what the problem is. But in any case, what we need to do is get a party going who's only platform is voting reform. The only goal that matters right now is the end of FPTP and the two party system. Once that's done having all these "fringe" parties will be a good thing because my "progressive" parties will agree on a lot of policy with your libertarians (e.g. surveillance, world police force, etc.).
- mindcrime 13y agoThe only goal that matters right now is the end of FPTP and the two party system. Once that's done having all these "fringe" parties will be a good thing because my "progressive" parties will agree on a lot of policy with your libertarians (e.g. surveillance, world police force, etc.). I agree that voting reform is crucial. Everything else really hinges on that. The fact that the "libertarian party" is a "thing" in the US is a large sign of what the problem is. Could you elaborate on that a little more? I think I get the gist of what you mean, but I'm not sure. FWIW, I'll just point out that the "libertarian movement" (or whatever you want to call it) in the US is bigger than just the "Libertarian Party". There are, for example, the "little l libertarians" within both the Republican and Democratic parties, who espouse and advocate for libertarian views. There are (or have been) multiple "libertarian" parties in the US. There's obviously the "Big L Libertarian" party, but there was also the "Boston Tea Party"[1], for one. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Tea_Party_(political_party) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Tea_Party_(political_par...
- flyinRyan 13y ago>Could you elaborate on that a little more? The Libertarian movement is an extreme right wing movement. They're correct with their international policy, and I agree with them on their stance on e.g. abortion and gay marriage (i.e. get rid of the religious concept of "marriage" in government). But they also have a lot of dangerous right wing stuff like massive deregulation, gold standard, etc. Having said that, I've voted Paul pretty much every time I had the chance because while I think his right wing stuff is dangerous and crazy, I don't think that stuff would get through. If we had actual representative government (i.e. the party make up of congress really reflected closely with the populations ideals instead of the red/blue setup we have now) it would work fine because we could get through all those things that your party and my party agree on.
- mindcrime 13y agoThe Libertarian movement is an extreme right wing movement. Everybody seems to think that, but I don't believe it to be the case. A better statement is that "Libertarians are right of Right and left of Left". So depending on your existing world-view, you would probably see the Libertarians as either radically Leftist or radically Rightist, and - in either case - you'd be partially correct and partially wrong. For example, Libertarians align with the left, and would go further than the standard American Left on many social issues: Abortion - Libertarians tend to be pro-choice and the LP platform specifically says that the State should not be involved in making those decisions. Drug laws - a typical American "Leftist" position might be "legalize marijuana". A Libertarian position would be more like "The State has no authority whatsoever to regulate what you put into your own body. End ALL drug laws". Death Penalty - Libertarians are generally opposed to the death penalty. Gay marriage / minority rights - Libertarians believe the Govt. should have no say in marriage at all, which implies that homosexual couples should be able to marry if they want. Of course, it also implies that others should be free to choose not to recognize that marriage, but hey... that's the price of freedom: You want to be free, you can't compel other people to behave the way you want them to. OTOH, yes, Libertarians tend to be more closely aligned with "the Right" on economic issues: taxation, trade, business regulation, etc. But I don't think it's fair to call the Libertarian movement "an extreme right wing movement". If for no other reason, because a simple "left / right" dichotomy is not a valid model for representing political orientation.
- sporkologist 13y ago> The only goal that matters right now is the end of FPTP and the two party system. Alas, there is so much money, power, and political infrastructure in maintaining the status quo. Changing this structure will not be popular and will quickly be relegated to "wacko" status, and minimized in the mainstream press..... which has a vested interest in maintaining the current system.
- javert 13y ago> . But I've seen some Pirates describe them as a "progressive" party, and I'm pretty skeptical of "progressives" and their policy positions. I agree with you. They are a progressive party, they are anti-individual rights, and that's why they have "Pirate" (literally a thief) in their name. The cause of liberty cannot be advanced by backing movements that do not base their ideas on a rational foundation.
- Apocryphon 13y agoYou're speaking from an Objectivist position, aren't you?
- javert 13y agoIn this case, I would say no. What I said is a very basic observation. Why do you ask?
- lukifer 13y agoA religious devotion to rationality is the most insidious form of irrationality.
- javert 13y agoI completely agree. I would have phrased it as: A religious devotion to "rationality" is the most insidious form of irrationality.
- electronous 13y ago> Anyway, for my money, it's the Libertarian Party that represents the path forward Time to shave your neckbeard.