4 ms·
Actually, it is. If we use services that do not keep logs or has real name policies, or if we favor companies that takes an active stance against surveillance r
by belorn 13y ago
Actually, it is. If we use services that do not keep logs or has real name policies, or if we favor companies that takes an active stance against surveillance rather than just buying from what ever is cheapest, we pushes society into a place where the spying is not socially accepted practices for for-profit organizations.
This event is already having that effect in EU. Governments is already creating policy/laws that favors national services over Google. If they go a step further and make a law that forbids moving privileged information to a US data cloud to be picked and prodded by spies and advertisers, that will have a real effect on Google, Microsoft, amazon and Apple. Suddenly, doctors can not use iphones connected with icloud for their practice. Lawyers can't use Microsoft 360 with mails going through Microsoft servers or store their mail in the cloud. Government can't purchase amazon cloud for developing. Even schools can't use Google docs when working with student records.
I have no doubt in me that the us government would listen to Google, Microsoft, amazon and Apple if such law was ever created.
- MisterWebz 13y agoIf the EU had their own Facebook and Google, it'll have their own intelligence agencies tapping data from those servers. Sure we can perhaps get them to change their minds by boycotting, but try asking a regular American citizen to fully disconnect from the internet.
- iuguy 13y agoThe EU does not have it's own singular intelligence agency. It's not a country. EU states may have their own but there's a big difference between the Netherlands, Spain and Sweden in terms of approach.
- MisterWebz 13y agoThe US and other parts of the world aren't one single country either, but that doesn't stop the US intelligence agencies from collecting data from all over the world.
- bad_user 13y ago> If the EU had their own Facebook and Google, it'll have their own intelligence agencies tapping data from those servers. This is a fallacy that gets repeated a lot. First of all, the EU is not a single entity, but rather a hydra with many heads. The competency and resources of "intelligence agencies" varies a lot by country, the privacy laws and the wire-taping/surveillance culture too. If you are speaking about the UK, sure, but try doing this in Germany. Also, in my country (Romania) the government wouldn't have the resources for it and they are too incompetent to cooperate with other agencies without people finding out about it. I also cannot see France doing this, since the French get pretty violent when they get upset. So what EU are you talking about exactly? Second, even if snooping of online activity does happen in an EU country, at least it's an EU intelligence agency you're talking about. This is relevant for US companies, because I don't know how much EU's governments care about our privacy, but I can assure you that they care about leaks to the US or China or other non-EU countries. Which means US companies will suffer for it. The USA was and is still seen as the benevolent dictator of the Internet. That's why we've been accepting your governance of TLDs, or your online services. That's why we've been blaming China for their tight control of online access. But if the US government keeps jerking around much, things will change.
- gioele 13y ago> First of all, the EU is not a single entity, but rather a hydra with many heads. The competency and resources of "intelligence agencies" varies a lot by country, the privacy laws and the wire-taping/surveillance culture too. Not that much. The is a single EU privacy directive, (95/46/EC), and an extension to provide better privacy for online data (2002/58/EC). All the member state have implemented the same directive. What changes among states are just implementation details (as a programmer would say). The thing to note here is that the EU directive provides a blanket exception for almost all governmental organizations and for all the police branches. This means that something like PRISM, if architectured in a proper way, would be completely legal. Truth be told, in EU most telcos and ISP are forced by the law to keep track of all the communications and forward them to the relevant authorities either in batch or on demand.
- 13y ago
- ig1 13y agoThere is such a law: http://export.gov/safeharbor/eu/eg_main_018365.asp http://export.gov/safeharbor/eu/eg_main_018365.asp US companies that want to hold EU data in the US have to guarantee the same level of protection the EU provides.
- belorn 13y agoDo that law prevent surveliance initiated by the state, and does it put liability at those who use the services rather than putting liability at those who offers the service? Ie, can someone use that law to sue a doctor who happens to use gmail/microsoft/icloud for communicate with his patients?