5 ms·
I do not like the title, but the central point is good. The real problem with PRISM is not that you, individually, are going to be targeted. It is that the to
by btilly 13y ago
I do not like the title, but the central point is good.
The real problem with PRISM is not that you, individually, are going to be targeted. It is that the tools have been put in place to subvert the political process by personally targeting anyone with views that are inconvenient for those of influence. These tools may be being used fairly now, but based on past history, we cannot assume that they will continue to be so.
And the past history to look at is not even that of distant times and places. Take a look at how the FBI under Hoover tried to affect the political process in the USA with COINTELPRO.
- alan_cx 13y agoChrist, imagine if Hoover had today's tool available to him. Imagine the reach and power of McCarthyism. I guess many would suggest that is exactly what we have right now. Just more subtle, opaque, and deniable.
- rayiner 13y ago> I guess many would suggest that is exactly what we have right now. Just more subtle, opaque, and deniable. I can't see how anyone who has studied American history could think that what we have now even approaches what existed at the time of McCarthyism. McCarthyism required a level of public acquiescence and homogeneity of thought that could only exist under the threat of Soviet domination and nuclear holocaust. The bogeyman of terrorism doesn't have nearly that kind of grip on the public consciousness. Heck, just look at the wars that were justified by the two fears: Korea (36,516 Americans dead) and Vietnam (58,209) versus Afghanistan (2,229) and Iraq (4,488). Not to minimize the causalities of those wars, but if you can measure the power of a scary idea by the number of U.S. soldiers that die before the public puts a stop to the war, then there is no comparison between the specter of communism versus the specter of terrorism.
- flyinRyan 13y agoBut communism was a made-up threat, just like terrorism is. They can ramp up the fear factor any time they want and now they have all that infra in place to support it.
- beedogs 13y agoThey really just need something to remind us once a generation or so. Then we all rally against whatever new bogeyman is presented. A huge chunk of our money is spent 'neutralizing' this new 'threat', and things go back to some new 'normal' for a little while.
- rayiner 13y agoAn aggressive, expansionist power with nuclear weapons pointed at us was not a "made-up" threat. Neither is international terrorist organizations conspiring to attack us. Both are factually verifiable threats. Reasonable people can disagree about the appropriate responses to those threats, but it's factually incorrect to say they are "made up." As an aside, for those claiming that terrorism poses no threat because it kills so few people, I'll offer the example of the Beltway Sniper attacks. More people probably died in traffic accidents in the D.C. metro area than were killed by the Beltway Sniper. But the chilling effect on everyday life was so much greater. It's hard do convey to someone the feeling of putting gas in your car on a sunny weekend day with the hair on your neck standing up because even though you know that there is a negligible chance of your being the victim of a sniper attack, the possibility scares you in a way that the possibility of death through heart disease, or hell the certainty of death through old age, cannot.
- flyinRyan 13y agoI see the nonsense works pretty well on you. >expansionist power with nuclear weapons pointed at us was not a "made-up" threat At the time of McCarthyism this wasn't really what was going on. What was going on was that capitalists were afraid communism would work. They saw rich and powerful people getting killed or displaced and the "plebs" running things and they were going to make sure it couldn't happen here. >Neither is international terrorist organizations conspiring to attack us International terrorist threat conspiracy theories. Nice. You mean the global terrorist group with all kinds of secret cells hidden under ever rock? Yea, that was all made up bullshit. Al Quaeda is a name we made up to be able to apply our own RICO laws after the first WTC bombing. And you may not realize it, but terrorist groups tend to hate each other as much as they hate anyone else. They are religious extremists after all. >but it's factually incorrect to say they are "made up." They are either utterly non-existent or so small as to be ignorable. >putting gas in your car on a sunny weekend day with the hair on your neck standing up because even though you know that there is a negligible chance of your being the victim of a sniper attack, the possibility scares you in a way that the possibility of death through heart disease, or hell the certainty of death through old age, cannot. What you are describing is irrational, emotional response. None the less, we can't make policy decisions about how you feel. And the media is largely to blame about this. The reported news should be proportional to the effect. The Boston marathon bomb should have been a byline on the local Boston news if it was mentioned at all.
- graeme 13y agoVery good point. I lived in Cuba for a few months. I was surprised to find that people were very open and vocal about their discontent with the economic situation. I eventually figured it out. Those people didn't matter. They weren't doing anything. Just venting steam. As soon as someone tried to actually change things, that's when they get bopped on the head. Most of us aren't activists. But we depend on them to drive change. If they get stifled, we get stifled.
- f1nch3r 13y agoI agree with the author's point. I'd like to add that the problem right now isn't that you'll be individually targeted. But a mechanism has been created that depends on benevolent rule. The loss of civil liberties tends to be looked at myopically.