3 ms·
Copyright should be 5 years by default, for free, but you can extend it every 5 years up to 20 years, but you'd have to pay say $1,000 every time. If you won't
by mtgx 13y ago
Copyright should be 5 years by default, for free, but you can extend it every 5 years up to 20 years, but you'd have to pay say $1,000 every time. If you won't extend it, then it goes to public domain by default.
We're living in the abundance age, which also means 90% of the stuff out there is "crap" and is quickly forgotten even by the authors. If they can't monetize it in 5 years, and can't afford to pay $1,000, then maybe it's not worth it, and should go to public domain so it doesn't get abused later. And who knows, maybe someone picks it up and makes it much better later, which will benefit the society and culture.
I think some of this is what this document proposes, too:
http://www.copyrightreform.eu/case-for-copyright-reform http://www.copyrightreform.eu/case-for-copyright-reform
- cookiecaper 13y agoHeh, I make the same suggestion for term in a thread further down. I don't think anyone who understands the space believes these vastly disproportionate copyright terms, sometimes potentially lasting well over 100 years, are fair, unless they're directly benefiting from the arrangement.
- rmc 13y agoI'd prefer a scaling back of rights. For the first (say) 5→10 years you get what you get now. Then for the next 5 years, it's basically under CC-NonCommerical-NoDerivatives, i.e. non-commercial non-derivate use is now legal. Then a few years later you lose the non-commerical protection (or maybe non-derivatives), gradullay until the work is essentially public domain.
- mapt 13y agoA counter-proposal: Copyright lasts one year without registration. At the end of that year, a work must be registered and a $100 fee put up to extend the term to 5 years. Every five years after that, the registration fee is increased by a factor of 10. This seems to address most of the problems I have with copyright, beyond the core conceit of whether it's valuable or not. I really don't understand how the Berne Convention's extremes can benefit a people other than as a hegemonic trade concession.
- themstheones 13y agoThis is a pretty good idea. I wonder what properties would make a $1 billion investment for five years a good investment? Star Wars maybe? That would be at the 40 year mark. And I am probably confusing copyright with trademark here. I suppose Disney could still own the rights for all star wars merchandise and new content even if they hypothetically lost the rights to A New Hope, due to trademarks, no? Because A New Hope surely isn't worth $1 billion for five years.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Copyright should be 5 years by default, for free, but you can extend it every 5 years up to 20 years, but you'd have to pay say $1,000 every time. I'd much prefer a regime with a short free period (I've always used 7 years, but 5 is close enough), after which you have to extend it by declaring a value and paying an an annual ad valorem tax on the declared value (say, 1-2%). The declared value would be the basis for a limitation on damages in infringement suits, and would also constitute a binding offer to transfer the copyright on the work to the public domain on a tender of payment of the stated amount.