3 ms·
I think looking at the economics of things is likely to give you a clearer picture, rather than feudal society.
by davidw 13y ago
I think looking at the economics of things is likely to give you a clearer picture, rather than feudal society.
- vbuterin 13y agoIndeed. Feudal society would have been very different if any eighteen year old whiz kid could start up his own manor and attract five million peasants over the course of two years and three venture capital cycles.
- ok_what_now 13y agoI don't mean this sarcastically or anything like that. Could help me understand what is wrong about what my taxonomy below? 18 year old kid = vassal customers = serfs venture capital = feudal lords The feudal concept has been pretty obvious(at least to me in my own reasoning) for at least 3 years now for me. That said I'm not an expert but that is my take right now.
- nhaehnle 13y agoMaybe that analogy could have some merit, but it is decidedly not the analogy that Schneier uses in his article. By putting forth your own take in this way, you are likely to derail the discussion without contributing anything other than your own grievance. Your attempt at an analogy should be discussed separately, if you think you can substantiate it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- john_b 13y agoIn a way, I think he is looking at the economics via this analogy. In Feudal Europe, the greatest economic resource was land. If you controlled lots of land, you had lots of power. But land was expensive to maintain and make productive. There was a lot of overhead, so merely owning it wouldn't make you rich. The feudal arrangement was that lords contracted the land out to vassals, who then employed serfs to work it. Protection and convenience flowed down, and in return wealth flowed up. Now the greatest economic resource is information, and controlling it gives you power. But producing information in a top-down manner is ineffective, so in return for protection and convenience, the serf-users of the internet age produce a wealth of information for their lords. The main difference in the power relationship seems to be that modern serf-users are free to choose their lords, leading to greater competition among rival lords, whereas feudal serfs were born into the service of a single vassal, who in turn served a single lord.