2 ms·
I would contend[1] that the biggest problem is actually the Senate's not directly representing the states. This has caused quite a bit of foolishness from the
by protomyth 13y ago
I would contend[1] that the biggest problem is actually the Senate's not directly representing the states. This has caused quite a bit of foolishness from the Senate (particularly for regulation implementation). The House is more a problem of districting psychosis. I don't think the House was ever really that pure[2].
1) I'll skip the whole republic / democracy argument until there is an actual democracy in the world.
2) read some stuff from the early 1800's, some Representatives didn't have a good opinion of those they represented
- jrs235 13y agoWhich is why we need to repeal the 17th amendment.
- tg3 13y agoI disagree. Having one of the most powerful legislative bodies elected by the state governments further concentrates power in the hands of a few. The 17th amendment made this country more democratic, not less, and it hasn't hade too many ill effects on the Senate itself.
- protomyth 13y agoThe 17th amendment lessened the power of the state and allowed for the current regulatory environment. We have Senators who have no caring or knowledge of what their actions do to the states. It broke the balance of our government. It didn't make the US more democratic, it increased the power of the two parties in Washington DC and allowed for them ignoring their local feelings. It concentrated power wonderfully.