3 ms·
"Conservative revolutionary ideals"? "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certa
by toyg 13y ago
"Conservative revolutionary ideals"? "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness" -- this was political and philosophical dynamite in the XVIII century, when kings and gods still reigned supreme over the whole world (in fact, it still is quite an incendiary statement in many countries). What were the writers trying to "conserve", exactly?
"U.K.'s bloodless internal revolutions"? Cromwell's Civil War was many things, but bloodless is not one of them.
I may or may not agree with parent, but your statements are very peculiar indeed.
- rayiner 13y agoThe founding fathers were no radicals. Whereas the leaders of the French revolution changed everything dramatically, the founders left the basic structure of American society more or less intact. "Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" was not an incendiary statement in late 1700's England. The 1688 Glorious Revolution had made Parliament ascendent in England, and the phrase "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" is a turn of Locke's phrase "life, liberty, and estate" which he published in the 1689 "Two Treatises of Government" in the aftermath of the Glorious Revolution. 17th century England was a fairly different place than is commonly taught in school. E.g (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dr._Bonham%27s_Case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dr._Bonham%27s_Case). Consequently, the level of continuity that existed between English rule and independence is usually vastly understated. The Constitution is best understood as a formalization of various strands of thought and practice that was already well-established in England by that time. And when I say "bloodless" I mean as far as revolutions go--compared to say the French revolution or the Chinese revolution.
- toyg 13y agoThe removal of aristocracy and the establishment of a Republic were extremely radical acts. Even in countries like England, where the merchant classes were on a dramatic rise and parliamentary rule was expanding in scope (and for which it was seen as a wildly anarchic state by most continental nobility), aristocracy was still fundamentally dominant in many areas of life -- which is why there was an American revolution in the first place: non-aristocratic colonists were excluded from most political and military appointments in the Kingdom. The fact that the founding fathers didn't have a holy call to abolish private property doesn't mean they weren't "radicals" -- that's a revisionist view with modern undertones. (and on the bloodless, I can assure you that the Civil War was as bloody as most revolutions. It was exactly out of horror for the consequences of that event that most English political movements self-moderated themselves since then, trying to maintain their fights mostly inside the boundaries of parliamentary rule.)
- dragonwriter 13y ago> this was political and philosophical dynamite in the XVIII century No, it wasn't, at least not in England. It was propaganda directed at what were already well-established political norms in the England. Pretty much the whole of the declaration, from the statement of principles at the beginning to the detailed list of particular grievances, was directed at explaining why the upper class landholding gentlemen of England's North American colonies were so upset at the upper class landholding gentlemen of the British Government for not treating them in the way that decent upper class landholding British subjects expected to be treated by their colleagues in government.
- toyg 13y agoSee my post above: they were treated unfairly because of this little thing called aristocracy, which was still dominant all over Europe; the fact that in some countries it was losing some of its powers doesn't mean that it wasn't still holding most of them. Removing aristocracy was an extremely radical act in the XVIII century, even for countries were the productive merchant classes had dramatically risen in relevance; it took another two centuries for most European countries to follow suit!