3 ms·
"first army in human history to be less concerned with the acquisition of power and control and more about giving that empowerment to the individuals we fight f
by dalke 13y ago
"first army in human history to be less concerned with the acquisition of power and control and more about giving that empowerment to the individuals we fight for"
That sounds incredible egocentric. Under what standard do you exclude all suffragettes and all abolitionists from this category?
- toyg 13y agoIn fact, the opposite is true: most revolutionary movements spurred from philosophical elaborations of wealthy and well-educated members of the ruling classes, which then allowed "inferiors" to claim their newly-defined 'natural rights'. People like Locke or Voltaire had little or nothing to gain from saying what they said, but were conscious that others would have been empowered by their words.
- dalke 13y agoThen you do not understand my objection. ChikkaChiChi said "We (meaning the tech elite) are first army in human history, ..." What makes this tech army categorically different than that of abolitionists? Don't Barlow, Gilmore, and Kapor, founders of the EFF, count as "wealthy and well-educated members of the ruling classes" just as much as Garrison and Tappan, founders of the American Anti-Slavery Society? "People like Locke or Voltaire had little or nothing to gain" You veer into a trap with that viewpoint. Frederick Douglass escaped from slavery, and fought against slavery and for equal rights. He had much to gain in his effort, including love and marriage. As a side-effect of doing so, and as a mechanism for achieving that goal, he gained political and social power. ChikkaChiChi said "less concerned with the acquisition of power and control", but that balance point becomes a subjective view. The only people that cannot fit those constraints are either 1) those with power and control but who don't want more, and 2) those who have no power or control, and therefore neither you nor I have likely heard of them.
- toyg 13y agoI actually agree with your opinion, sorry if it wasn't clear :) I was just pointing out that, generally speaking, many movements who were "fighting for our oppressed fellow man" were in fact produced not by the oppressed, but by dissenting elements of the oppressing classes. Not all of them, of course.
- dalke 13y agoAhh, I didn't understand. I couldn't figure out where "the opposite is true" was supposed to apply. How do you tell when a movement was produced by the oppressed, but where the strongest and most influential voice that the oppressing class hears is from a dissenting member of that class? Given how quickly Luther's views spread, it can't be that he was the only one who didn't like the actions of the Catholic church. I still feel that you're walking into a trap. If a member of the oppressed class become notable and influential, then that person's work could be recast as a way to achieve personal power and thereby become part of an oppressing class. If so, then oppression is perpetual until we figure out how to make 7 billion people be equally notable and influential. How does a dissenting element of the oppressing class ever leave that class?