6 ms·
I remember reading somewhere that the policemen in the raid did not know what were going on, or even who the target was. I wouldn't be surprised if they thought
by belorn 13y ago
I remember reading somewhere that the policemen in the raid did not know what were going on, or even who the target was. I wouldn't be surprised if they thought they were taking down a terrorist cell, given that the personal used was the counter-terrorism special tactics Group.
Reading the Wikipedia article about the task force, their job is in dealing with high risk situations involving armed offenders and possible terrorism related events. They also train with New Zealand Special Air Service Commandos. In that context, the raid makes much more sense in how it was conducted, with silencers, helicopters, dogs and 20-30+ personal. The real question then comes to who in the command structure decided to use such group for serving a warrant, and collecting evidence for an assisting copyright infringement case. Given the nature of the crime, the low threat level (admitted in court), this is rather uniquely in history. One might also wonder how much influence the FBI had in the decision.
- contingencies 13y agoThe audio from the helicopter features radio reports from the ground team with words to the effect "target secured" (ie. they knew they were after Kim specifically, once he was restrained that was their objective completed).
- xtrumanx 13y agoI believe by what belorn meant regarding the police not knowing who the target was, was the they didn't know they were after a guy for copyright infringement as opposed to a armed and dangerous individual.
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoWhy the distinction? Schmitz was armed when he was found. Also, he was arrested not only for copyright infringement, but also for racketeering and money laundering. Those are serious crimes, usually the domain of organized crime.
- contingencies 13y agoThe parent comment is either ill-informed or deliberate misinformation. Kim wasn't armed. There was a fully licensed rifle in the premises, but it wasn't with him. There was no warrant granted to arrest him, no due process, and the prime minister of the country has given him a personal apology for the event, which has been admitted to be a gross perversion of lawful policing. Somewhere along the line he realized it was a police raid, but chose to wait in the panic room anyway, with the door open, to avoid startling anyone and putting himself at risk of being shot. Even so, and despite knowing of the existence of the room, it took police 13 minutes to find him, and when they finally did they weren't particularly gentle in apprehending him. Dotcom claimed he was punched in the face and kicked to the floor, and that one officer stood on his hand once he was down. http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/118975-Kim-Dotcom-Raid-Video-Goes-Public http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/118975-Kim-Dotcom-...
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoFrom the New Zealand police statement: “Despite our staff clearly identifying themselves Mr Dotcom retreated into the house and activated a number of electronic locking mechanisms. While Police neutralised these locks he then further barricaded himself into a safe room within the house which officers had to cut their way into. Once they gained entry into this room they found Mr Dotcom near a firearm which had the appearance of a shortened shotgun.” http://www.police.govt.nz/news/release/30638.html http://www.police.govt.nz/news/release/30638.html
- belorn 13y agoThe gun in question, discovered in a safe just metres from where police arrested the German internet lord at his Auckland mansion, My whole childhood, we had a gun cabinet full of weapons in technically my room. However, during my whole childhood, I was not armed. See the difference?
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoI assume that gun cabinet was kept locked and you couldn’t get in. Schmitz’s safe was open. Schmitz was hiding in his panic room, refused to come out for the police, and had a shotgun with him in that room. If not technically armed, he certainly created a high risk situation.
- dangoldin 13y agoI obviously don't know much but it seems stupid to not tell your team who they're going after. They would use that information to plan the breach and I'd suspect a good squad leader would demand to know before going in.
- belorn 13y agoI was wondering about it some more, and tried to find where I could had read it. Sadly, I can't find it so take the statement with a bit of salt. Might just been a comment someone made regarding the officer who asked the nanny if she had any weapons or bombs. (http://gizmodo.com/5882967/watch-how-the-special-forces-busted-into-megaupload-mansion http://gizmodo.com/5882967/watch-how-the-special-forces-bust...) Or it maybe my memory is a bit faulty and what I remember is regarding the search warrant used by the police. (http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/06/mega-victory-kim-dotcom-search-warrants-invalid-mansion-raid-illegal/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/06/mega-victory-kim-...) The article describe how police officers didn't know what they were looking for when executing the warrant. As the judge put it, the people executing the warrant "were not the investigating officers and had limited knowledge of the operation," despite being briefed before the raid went down. If I do find the article, I will post it. Maybe its was in the court document.
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoIt’s obviously not true. How else would they know who to arrest? In that case, Schmitz could’ve just walked off the compound.
- dopamean 13y agoHaving a photo and name of someone isn't the same as knowing who they are.
- genwin 13y agoThey might've realized when they saw the big shiny "D O T C O M" sculpture on the grounds. You can see part of it in the video.
- jwoah12 13y agoI didn't know who Kim Dotcom was before this ordeal, and that certainly wouldn't strike me as a last name if I didn't already know.
- larrys 13y ago"The real question then comes to who in the command structure decided to use such group for serving a warrant" "such group" needs practice similar to how firemen use controlled fires to practice their skills. As such it makes total sense that you would use this as an opportunity to hone the groups skills for a time when the target is much more important. I've seen cases where the NYPD sends officers overseas to (sorry can't find a link) help with matters that have nothing to do with NYC at all. I assume this has to do with some kind of practice for when they need the same at home.
- charonn0 13y ago"They needed the practice" is possibly the worst excuse I've heard for the overwhelming force used here.
- larrys 13y agoHave no clue why I'm being downvoted for expressing a potential reality about the situation based on past observation. Nice going HN.
- charonn0 13y agoTo my mind the "training" excuse for the use of force here is more appalling even that the accusations that they were doing the FBI's bidding. Fire departments generally don't set fire to some guy's house for training purposes.
- shpxnvz 13y ago> "such group" needs practice similar to how firemen use controlled fires to practice their skills Firemen don't go around setting people's homes on fire in order to practice putting them out.
- larrys 13y agoOh geez the point is they use it for practice. Nobody is advocating (and it wasn't the point of my comment) that a situation is setup for that purpose.