2 ms·
1. "Presumably, if someone asks if you've ever been served a NSL, you're supposed to lie and say "no."" This is an awful large presumption. You could simply s
by DannyBee 13y ago
1. "Presumably, if someone asks if you've ever been served a NSL, you're supposed to lie and say "no.""
This is an awful large presumption. You could simply say nothing, and not answer.
2. the only courts to ever confront the NSL's compelled silence have ruled it unconstitutional.
There are zero courts that have ever okay'd this.
3. The "not your lawyer" part is now explicitly wrong, as the law now states (and has since 2006), "shall disclose to any person (other than those to whom such disclosure is necessary to comply with the request or an attorney to obtain legal advice or legal assistance with respect to the request)".
4. Judicial review of any NSL may now be had (again, since Mar 9, 2006), in a normal district court. See "18 USC § 3511 - Judicial review of requests for information"
There are plenty of reasons to generate large amounts of righteous indignation about NSL's, but it would be nice if you actually got the law right in the hyperbole.
- nostromo 13y agoThanks for the correction, I'm glad to hear the law was modified. I went back to the story in Wired and I see they did make note of the change to the law.