3 ms·
I'd love to see how a post-filesystem device would organize the content for my graphic novel. I've got about a hundred Illustator source files, one for every p
by egypturnash 13y ago
I'd love to see how a post-filesystem device would organize the content for my graphic novel.
I've got about a hundred Illustator source files, one for every page. A similar number of pngs for posting online. A subdirectory full of source files for my model sheets - mostly Illustrator files, and some 3D models for a swoopy car. And another subdir for rendered copies of those model sheets. On an external drive (space is at a premium on my Air) I've got print-res TIFFs of each page, two for some pages due to crazy printing tricks I'm doing. And an InDesign template that I use to generate an InDesign file that includes all those pages, which I finally use to generate a PDF that I send off to the printer.
This is not an especially sophisticated thing to do. People have been drawing comics for ages, and have needed much the same kinds of organizations well before the computer. A pile of illustration boards in a closet, labeled as being this story or that story. A filing cabinet with my notes, models, and reference. Et cetera.
As long as the OS and apps have no real global concept of "a project", we'll need file systems to, well, give us a system to organize our files.
Or maybe I'm a Luddite who can't imagine the critical change in usability that will result in being thoroughly free of directory trees. It's quite possible. But I sure don't see it in what we have now.
- icebraining 13y agoAs long as the OS and apps have no real global concept of "a project", we'll need file systems to, well, give us a system to organize our files. I think that's exactly what the author says will happen: "(...) This will help apps automatically organize and index relevant information so that the interface’s search function can access and integrate content in a much smarter way, making the file and folder concept obsolete. (...)"
- XorNot 13y agoI tend to be of the notion that pushing data organization into the application space is just asking for trouble most of the time. I'd prefer to have one big, consistent way to organize things, then a few dozen applications each with their own take on it. To me the ideal system is one where the filesystem (or probably a very thin abstraction layer) can be intelligent enough to do sensible things with files when they get saved, and my applications work with whatever scheme I tell it to enforce.