5 ms·
I don't care about flatness or skeutransmogrification or whatnot, but the damn thing must WORK. Look at his iMessage screen comparison [1]: yes, the old screen
by toyg 13y ago
I don't care about flatness or skeutransmogrification or whatnot, but the damn thing must WORK.
Look at his iMessage screen comparison [1]: yes, the old screen looks a bit geocities, but you can actually read text very well; the new screen is almost unreadable. The prime aim of iMessage is to make people read text, not to look cool.
It doesn't matter if there are options to thicken the font -- the whole point of OSX/iOS UI was that you should not need options, because defaults should be good enough for most people. This is clearly not the case with what we've seen of iOS7, and that's a problem.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/mattgemmell/9023510971/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/mattgemmell/9023510971/
- bennyg 13y agoTo me, reading messages is a more pleasant experience on iOS 7 compared with previous versions. It's actually one of my favorites of the new stock apps they created. Sure the design is a little lacking, but as far as usability goes - it's actually quite nice.
- jonahx 13y ago+1, the old screen seems much more usable to me as well
- Yhippa 13y agoI wonder what the use case was for fading the chat bubble color as you go later in time? I haven't seen iOS 7 in action yet but I wonder what happens when you scroll up: how do the colors change? At a glance the earlier messages I would have sent look harder to read.
- bennyg 13y agoAs the messages move closer to the bottom of the screen they become more opaque. So as you scroll, the things that preside close to the bottom of the actual device, that are on screen at that moment, will be totally opaque.
- paganel 13y agoFrom a fellow know-nothing when it comes to "flatness" and skeu-something I was a little bit surprised when the author complained that the old "receive a call" interface was full with alert-like buttons. They are supposed to be "Alert" buttons, for crying out loud, as in you're asleep in your bed, the phone starts ringing which means you have been "alerted", you're now woken up and ready to answer the call or deny it. Which brings me to my second point, that is where is the "Deny" button/action in the new interface. ? I could only see "Answer" and "Remind me later".
- blocking_io 13y agoYou have always been able to deny calls using the power button on top. Presumably that method is now compulsory.
- baudehlo 13y agoThat doesn't deny the call. It just turns the ringer/buzzer off until they give up.
- parasubvert 13y agoIf you double click the top button, it does deny the call.
- shurcooL 13y agoYou can press it a second time after that to "deny" the call.
- ajanuary 13y agoPressing it again will deny the call.
- paul_f 13y agoIf Jony Ive had wanted you to deny calls, he would have given you a button for it. Now stop complaining and answer your phone.
- 13y ago
- jcampbell1 13y agoYou can't possibly determine the legibility of font rendering designed for a 727k pixel display based on a 115k pixel screenshot. Have you tried the current Gmail app? It uses thin fonts, and I don't find it to be a problem.
- hcarvalhoalves 13y agoThe thing is fricking white Helvetice Neue on a light blue bubble. You don´t need a retina display to conclude this is unreadable. You just need common sense.
- Vieira 13y ago> I don't care about flatness or skeutransmogrification or whatnot, but the damn thing must WORK. Absolutely. I don't understand how so many people are focusing on the highs and lows of the UI but are ignoring serious UX problems like the one you pointed. Apple says "Nothing we’ve ever created has been designed just to look beautiful. That’s approaching the opportunity from the wrong end." but then they change the perfectly readable Messages screen to a less readable one that has the only advantage of arguably looking better. And it's not the only problem IMHO. On that screen used to be a send button that invited interaction. You look there and you know that it's "actionable". Now in the new version there is no button, only a gray text with "No Perceived Affordance" that looks more like a description than an "actionable" element. The most important "action" on that screen happens when you press a gray text on a gray background! And the call screen? On the iOS6 one it was easier to read the name of the person who is calling because the white text is above a black overlay giving it enough contrast. On the new one the text although bigger is lighter (as in less bold) and is directly on the image. Light backgrounds (sky, clouds, etc) will make the text barely visible. Also how can I reject a call? There is nothing on that screen supporting the second most important functionality that is expected from it. Even accepting the call is now more complicated. The size and position of the elements makes more sense now but the text is lighter (less readable) and it's now more complicated to accept a call: before you only needed to touch accept, now you need to slide. The home screen: even ignoring the aesthetics that I personally don't like, it's undeniable that the text is much more readable with iOS6. The small border and shadow made it readable with virtually any background. Also the icons were easier on the eyes, the new bright colors tire/irritate the eyes more. Also the relationship between icons and the functionality they represent was already hard in some cases. For instance for someone that didn't know Safari it was not easy to tell which was the browser and which was the compass from just the icons. Also the photos icon was not obvious at all and the Music vs iTunes Store icons are almost the same with different backgrounds but now it got worse: none of the exisiting problems got any better and at least reminders, settings and game center got worse. Of course there are a lot of screens that got better imho. Music, contact view, the calendar, clocks, compass, weather...
- shock-value 13y agoI actually don't have anything to add to your comment, but I just wanted to say I agree 100% with literally everything you wrote here. These are my exact gripes with the new version, expressed better than I think I could have.
- cormullion 13y agoAs a counter-example (although I agree with you), the hideous and unusable directions on iOS 6 Maps (the all-capitals blue and white highway sign look) seems to have given way to something more readable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]