5 ms·
One thing to consider: if you use an alternative to the major services...doesn't that make it easier to find you? You've effectively joined a much smaller hayst
by danso 13y ago
One thing to consider: if you use an alternative to the major services...doesn't that make it easier to find you? You've effectively joined a much smaller haystack.
I guess how much of a risk this depends on where you see the vector of attack. If you think the NSA has one decade forward on decryption ability, then what does it matter if Facebook/etc hands over the data or if you've trusted another encryption scheme?
But consider this scenario: the NSA knows that one member of a group may be a person of interest, with the rest being innocent (for example, a leaker within an organization). What draws more attention: the person who is sending all of their traffic through GMail, etc...or the person who, for some reason, is using an obscure service at particular hours of the day? Even the use of Tor might be a flag.
And if your counter-argument is, "Well, so what? They won't be able to break the encryption on [so-and-so-independent service]?". Well, they don't have to. They just have to find someone who is exhibiting a reasonable amount of suspicious behavior and then observe them in other ways or get their associates/family members to flip...Investigations don't succeed or fail based on the unlocking of a key file...it's the work done around the secret that can reveal the secret.
edit: An analogy - You wish to have an affair without your spouse noticing. Since affairs in relationships are not an unheard of occurrence, your spouse isn't going to actively suspect you of it, but he wouldn't ignore signs of an affair either. Having the affair in your own home isn't practical, and you choose not to do it at the Ramada that's just blocks away from your home/workplace because, well, there's so many people there, and there's the possibility that a mutual acquaintance will see you and then tell on you.
So instead, you and your affairee agree to meet each other at a small bed and breakfast that is 1 hour away from your city and so small that no one you know probably even knows about it, and no one at the B&B will care who you are or know who your spouse is.
So are you safe? Well, only until your spouse finds it weird that on occasional days after work, you're driving in a direction that there doesn't seem to be any reason for you to go, and these occasions end up with you being gone for several hours. And in one such occasion, you were noticed carrying what seemed like a bag for a bottle of wine.
By going the obscure route, you've deflected one kind of exposure and opened yourself up to a whole new kind of suspicion.
- mtgx 13y agoThat's why we need to push for popular services like Skype, Hangouts, Gmail and others to implement these technologies to make them mainstream so most people use them.
- danso 13y agoNot sure what technologies you're referring to, but in regards to the OP, the OP is arguing that people use replacement services (Diaspora vs Facebook, for example) so that the NSA and such have a harder time finding you...But if you ascribe the kind of capabilities and motivations to the NSA that would make you this concerned (the collection/mirroring of all traffic, legal authority to request what they want, encryption well ahead of the state-of-the-art, and the information architecture to make broad-scale analysis possible)...then you're not really diluting anything and opening yourself up to other attack vectors.
- tankbot 13y ago> if you use an alternative to the major services...doesn't that make it easier to find you? You've effectively joined a much smaller haystack. No. Because the 'haystack' you are (accidentally) referring to is a ginormous indexed/searchable database. All of their data goes to the same place, so it doesn't matter where it comes from. Your argument through analogy is not applicable but let me clarify for you: They are not watching you. They are watching the Ramada and everyone who enters, exits, and everything they do while there. All of this information goes into organized storage until they need to dig it up. They can't watch the bed and breakfast because the windows are blacked out (encryption). So you are safer there. Security through obscurity is an awful policy to start with and only fails harder when applied to a situation like this.
- danso 13y agoSecurity through obscurity is never a great mindset, but neither is the mindset that security doesn't come without significant tradeoffs, tradeoffs that may reveal you inadvertently. And you misunderstand the analogy. They don't need to watch you having an affair (through the windows). They only need to see that you're driving to an out-of-the-way B&B. They don't even have to interrogate you directly, just any one else who comes out of that small venue. Ergo, the "haystack" is smaller. To use another analogy: what do you think former CIA director David Petraeus was done in by? The fact that he used GMail and that activity on his account triggered an FBI omnisearch? Or that his mistress engaged in illegal activity and did not take the steps to separate her real-life identity from the anonymous GMail account?