2 ms·
>There will be a minor flood of papers pre-registering sketchy theories Does pre-registering papers somehow cause all journals to lose all editorial control?
by pessimizer 13y ago
>There will be a minor flood of papers pre-registering sketchy theories
Does pre-registering papers somehow cause all journals to lose all editorial control?
>Some authors will publish their negative results, but many will forget them and move on to more fertile grounds.
Why would they forget about something that they have already publicly accepted an obligation to publish, and how would that effect their careers?
>The bulk of these maybe-so works will be taken as positive evidence even if positive effects are never found or if negative effects are published.
First of all, right now the media (and other scientists, and regulators) jump on the single published vaguely positive result, unaware of the 99 negative results that were never published. It would be an improvement to reduce this list to only the media, who are intentionally being fooled for the sake of a good linkbait headline.
Lastly, there should be enough of a volume and normalization of pre-registrations that if you want to pretend like the statement of a question constitutes the answer, people will laugh at you.