4 ms·
This is going to be about a redefinition of privacy. It was ok for governments to spy on other countries governments (and so their citizens). In this name we
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
This is going to be about a redefinition of privacy.
It was ok for governments to spy on other countries governments (and so their citizens). In this name we put satellites over us all. The problem with this is the satellites spied on everyone, and governments were supposed to ignore the right bits.
But now if a government wants to spy, it mostly needs to watch what people do or do not do online (I will bet real spies have some really odd online "tells")
So if its ok to spy on another government, it's going to be necessary to spy on everyone everywhere, and then ignore certain bits. Like satellites but much more finer grained. Oh and if you want to catch a spy in the USA, you need to spy on all US citizens to watch for those "tells".
What we want is not for governments to pretend the Internet does not exist, but rather to ensure that they cannot use the information found for anything we do not specifically legislate.
I am pretty sure this is something like an extension of the fourth amendment in US terms.
It's a redefinition of privacy - not that no-one knows, but that no-one is allowed to make use of knowing.
That's the trade-off we face. We get the Internet, we give up what we currently think of as privacy.
- pyre 13y ago1. The machinery being put into place is a dictator's wet dream. By creating the infrastructure, we are putting a gun to our heads, and trusting the person holding it (the government) to not pull the trigger. The government may be benevolent now, but that may not always be the case. 2. Once the machinery is in place, it makes it that much easier to change directions. Just look at how all of the powers granted by the PATRIOT Act are used to non-terrorism related investigations like the War on Drugs, or the War on (Paid) Sex. Look to the censorship programs in Europe / Australia. They were put into place to block supposedly 'only' child pornography. Now they are used to block other things. 3. How are we supposed to make sure that things aren't being abused when everything happens behind closed doors, and the members of Congress cleared to see more specifics aren't allowed to see very much of hte system.
- lifeisstillgood 13y ago> dictator's wet dream I expect the same was said about satellites, telephone tapping, etc Our defence against dictators does not lie in technology but in the ballot box. 2. Again the ballot box is the defence, but the reason it gets used is people are educated about the technology and the implications of abuse. I doubt that a US to ernment that took away a right to silence would suffer a few outcries from geeks. They would get roasted. (Unlike the UK) 3. Secret courts are banned for that reason. I think I would like to see a definition of national security like "ten thousand dead" or 3 % loss of GDP. Then when. That gets invoked we can make a sensible guess about how often it's likely. Otherwise, you put it in open court Individuals are not the only ones to lose privacy in the coming years. Go ernment a will lose more
- pyre 13y agoThe government has more resources than common citizens have. Sure the government is losing privacy, but citizens can't be invasive of the government's privacy in the same way that the government is being invasive of citizens' privacy.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoin aggregate we can, and will.
- pyre 13y agoCan and will invade the government's privacy how? Maybe by forcing them to be more transparent, but I don't view that as "invading the government's privacy."