3 ms·
[citation needed]. Again, i have seen this in argument after argument. Nobody has yet provided any legal authority that states it is constitutional or legal f
by DannyBee 13y ago
[citation needed].
Again, i have seen this in argument after argument. Nobody has yet provided any legal authority that states it is constitutional or legal for the government to compel forced lies.
They can compel silence, for sure.
There is plenty of authority in other contexts (IE not national security), that the government cannot compel you to speak misleading or non-truthful information.
I wish this idea that everyone must be lying because the government can legally, force them to, would stop.
I imagine someone started with the NSL gag orders, which compel silence, and then just started saying they compel you to lie instead (which they don't).
In fact, even the compel silence part of the NSL was found unconstitutional.
- flyinRyan 13y agoYou're interneting wrong. Of course we can't give official links pointing to where this is policy, that's the point of the policy! But from the information we've gathered so far it very much appears to be the case that companies are forced to deny getting requests from the government, not just be silent. And don't bother trying to work out how the law allows this, we're not even allowed to know what some of the laws even are.
- DannyBee 13y ago"And don't bother trying to work out how the law allows this, we're not even allowed to know what some of the laws even are. " This is false. You may not be allowed to know some internal agency regulations, but that's always been the case. What laws do you think you can't know of, exactly?