13 ms·
Greenwald: Snowden Has Provided ‘Thousands’ Of Docs, ‘Dozens’ Are Newsworthy
- FreeKill 13y agoLess talk and more publishing. The longer they discuss just how great the additional documents are going to be, the more time the NSA/USA has time to try convince the guardian not to publish...
- jeremyflores 13y agoFrom a strategic role, what Greenwald's doing is a smart move. If they were to dump everything out in the public in quick succession, the news cycle (and, by extent, the public) would absorb the information and move on. Timed releases would continually stoke the fire and prevent people from forgetting about it.
- danielharan 13y agoIf the Guardian didn't publish him, @ggreenwald still has some 171k followers on Twitter.
- droopyEyelids 13y agoIf anyone reading this doesn't have strong allegiance to either political party, you might enjoy his twitter as much as I do https://twitter.com/ggreenwald https://twitter.com/ggreenwald I'm almost disappointed by this leak because of how it might affect the diversity of mr greenwald's tweets.
- Vivtek 13y agoFor a while. Don't worry, Greenwald will always have plenty of slimy things to report on.
- dpeck 13y agoIt is disappointing how news organizations seek to gravitate towards making themselves the center of whatever story they're telling. Isn't the role of narrator an incredibly important enough part of every tale?
- davorak 13y agoI am not sure if there is a more effective method of spreading the knowledge however. If it was all dumped at once very few people would be able to absorb it and understand it in a timely fashion and many would probably give up and move on. Yes they benefit by drawing it out, but the same technique seems to elicit deeper impact on the public.
- danielharan 13y agoIf you were reporting on these leaks like Greenwald, wouldn't you have a dead man's switch? What does it say about a reporter's job that they would have to fear for their very lives? Reporters are now protagonists since states spy on them and use dirty tactics to prevent them from doing their jobs. I don't think many of them wanted that role when they started.
- pvnick 13y agoI'm really excited! I like the incremental release, I think it builds momentum in the way that a full dump could not. Just as one story has been thoroughly explored, the next one comes out.
- wavefunction 13y agoGreat point. I'd like to see David Brooks and the rest of the useful idiots try and struggle to keep up with the releases. I'd like to imagine folks as smart as Snowden, Poitras, and Greenwald have approached the releases of these documents strategically, considering the inevitable responses from the status quo and its servants. I'd imagine it wouldn't be hard to predict their responses to each type of revelation. They try to downplay the scope of the snooping? Retort with documents showing the number of collaborating service providers and types of materials gathered. They try to downplay the impact of this on innocent Americans? Release documents showing specific abuses. etc. and ad nauseaum until the hypocrites, phonies, and apologists are exposed for exactly what they are. I suppose only time will tell, but I know a lot of people that are getting more and more interested in this.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I'd like to see David Brooks and the rest of the useful idiots try and struggle to keep up with the releases. Its not like Brook's facile drivel takes all that much effort; its not like its designed to stand up to scrutiny by anyone thinking deeply, its just to give people an excuse not to think deeply.
- dataisfun 13y agoI don't think they'll highlight specific abuses, as greenwald already commented on the difficulty of that. If you point out some innocent being surveilled, you've just exposed them to the world. If you point out someone guilty being surveilled (though guilt would be impossible to determine a priori and from their perch), you've just tipped them off. I'm very curious to see the content of the next releases, and like the one of the commenters above, I do hope there's a deadman switch, though killing greenwald now would be an epic mistake on the govt's part. THAT would set off a firestorm. More than likely, they've already hacked his computer and have read the docs and are preparing how to respond to the upcoming revelations.
- cheald 13y agoI feel really jaded for daring to think it, but I really hope he has the releases set up on a deadman's switch.
- cgag 13y agoIt'd be naive to not think about it.
- rl3 13y agoSuch things can backfire: http://www.zdnet.com/blog/btl/wikileaks-insurance-file-decrypted-names-of-informants-exposed/56553 http://www.zdnet.com/blog/btl/wikileaks-insurance-file-decry... EDIT: Didn't see the Twitter update at the bottom, my apologies.
- ck2 13y agoupdate: In a tweet, the @wikileaks says: "WikiLeaks 'insurance' files have not been decrypted. All press are currently misreporting. There is an issue, but not that issue."
- Taylorious 13y agoWell he did allude to all of the insane things he supposedly had access to like operative names, safe houses, etc. even saying something to the extend of bring the NSA down in an afternoon. If I was going to have deadman's switch, it would be all that stuff. He doesn't seem like the type to do it outright, he doesn't seem to want to cause that level of chaos and damage (if indeed he does have the power), but who knows what will happen if he shows dead somewhere.
- smegel 13y agoI really dislike the way Wikileaks and this journalist get huge dumps of information then trickle feed it out, and ultimately don't end up releasing most of it. It's almost like they are deliberately giving the USG enough time to shut them down. Infuriating would be an understatement.
- pyre 13y agoOn the other hand, trickling it out keeps the entire issue at the fore-front of the public's attention rather than burning out in a week and being done with it. Also, as some have said, it allows those involved to come out with statements which may later be contradicted by further releases of evidence (i.e. giving the government a chance to hang themselves).
- forgottenpass 13y agoThere was an NPR interview a few years ago with someone at Wikileaks (must have been Assange, do they have another public face?). They used to release information in dumps, nobody paid attention. Teasing it out was the only way to get the media to bite. It's not a very appealing strategy to those who just want the information, but a response to the current state of affairs, I guess.
- smegel 13y agoWell...provide the dump to as many other journalists as you can first, then trickle it out. It just doesn't seem like a valid reason to sit on the whole lot yourself, surely providing a guarantee that the information will get out eventually is more important than the media management aspect. And besides, based on this theory, the stream of information being released should speed up, as once you have the worlds attention, they will pay attention to more. But we tend to see an initial release of explosive information, followed by a gradually diminishing stream of information - I am thinking back to Cablegate in particular - until it basically switches off and you never hear anything again.
- thwi 13y agoIs there any sense of the law which would allow US authorities to seize or otherwise prohibit these additional documents from being published?
- mindcrime 13y agoI'm sure Peter King would say yes. He, or some others, would probably try to spin it to fall under the Espionage Act[1] or something. Whether or not that would stand up to Supreme Court scrutiny is, I think, an open question. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Espionage_Act_of_1917 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Espionage_Act_of_1917
- dataisfun 13y agoPeter King makes my teeth hurt. I'm really shocked that guy says what he does without any irony for his obvious authoritarian overtones.
- minimize_me 13y agoAlso the fact that he is a supporter of the IRA, both in his statements for the past 40 or so years, and also materially (back during the Troubles). How the hell does a guy like that end up as Committee Chairman for Homeland Security?
- wl 13y agoThe US Government sought an injunction preventing the New York Times from publishing parts of the Pentagon Papers. The case quickly got to the Supreme Court, which threw out the injunction 6-3. It was one of those rare decisions in which nine justices generated ten different opinions. One was a basic, unsigned opinion of the court throwing out the injunction with barely any reasoning because the majority could only agree on the result, not the process to get there. Suffice it to say, this is a very complicated question. I'm inclined to believe that any attempts to prevent journalists from publishing additional documents like the ones now in question will be quashed. But it's not a sure thing.
- trrocket 13y agoScary that Greenwald has to be quite so specific about Snowden's state of mind. Between the lines, he's not about to jump off a bridge. It suggests that they're genuinely worried about what someone might do to Snowden.
- cheald 13y agoIt's bordering on conspiracy theory territory, but "threat to the government commits 'suicide'" is so expected, it's cliche.
- trrocket 13y agoI agree, but it is the fact that Greenwald (rather than just the average conspiracy theorist) clearly has this on his mind that I found interesting.
- orblivion 13y agoAnd as such I wish Snowden had a verified Twitter account.
- orblivion 13y agoI hope I wasn't misunderstood. I'd want the Twitter account so he could verify to the public that he was still alive.
- 13y ago
- rtpg 13y agoMaybe this time around they'll ask for comment or whatever from the concerned sources so that they can avoid publishing so much incorrect info this time around. I found it really hard to get angry at the PRISM stuff considering that pretty much every major article went through major revisions over the following 48 hours. Also, the "direct access to servers" meme that was categorically false doesn't help to take it seriously. When the people behind the scandal can spend the entire news cycle raising legitimate criticisms and contradictions to the published articles, it's hard to get mad.
- pvnick 13y ago>Also, the "direct access to servers" meme that was categorically false doesn't help to take it seriously I don't think this was ever determined. The documents specifically stated that access to the servers is "direct," and Glenn Greenwald seems to be sticking to his guns on that point.
- gohrt 13y agoPlease describe (in a sketched terms) a technical method by which anyone could get "direct access" to the user-data servers of Facebook, AOL, Google, etc. Remember that each company has its own homegrown user-data data storage format, homegrown distributed data storage system, homegrown datacenters(!), and firewalls. These companies aren't running MySQL or Oracle, and these systems are constantly being updated with new features and data model migrations. Does that seem plausible? Contrast against what has been freely admitted since NSLs started appearing: Each company sets up a "safe-deposit" server for delivering specific one-off subsets of subpoena'd data, and the company's engineers deliver data to that server upon demand.
- pvnick 13y agoI am a "big data" engineer, and I have no idea how they could do something like this. However my inability to theorize a potential method of collecting this data is not evidence for/against its existence. Remember the NSA employs some of the most brilliant software engineers and mathematicians on the planet whose job it is over the course of years to figure this sort of stuff out. I'm sure they've got a few tricks up their sleeve. Time will tell of course, and more revelations are reportedly "imminent"
- subsystem 13y agoIt seems like many have missed some things about the slides that were leaked. Only five pages of the 41 page presentation has been released so far[0]. The fifth page was released after the initial release and contains the phrase "directly from the servers"[1]. The rest of the presentation allegedly also contain more technical details[2]. [0] http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/06/snowden-powerpoint/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/06/snowden-powerpoint/ [1] http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/08/nsa-prism-server-collection-facebook-google http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/08/nsa-prism-server... [2] https://twitter.com/ggreenwald/status/343410562245480449 https://twitter.com/ggreenwald/status/343410562245480449
- Jabbles 13y agoIs Greenwald technical enough to understand the content? Or is it just going to be buzzwords that have no real technical meaning? The slice deck already looks like someone was presenting to non-technical management - why would they have put highly technical details in there too?
- ceejayoz 13y agoThat the slide deck isn't technical doesn't mean Snowden didn't have access to the technical stuff too. Greenwald presumably has plenty of access to technical advisors at the Guardian and elsewhere who can help sift through.
- eightyone 13y agoHaven't you got the memo yet? According to the media we can't trust Snowden because he didn't graduate high school.
- mattzito 13y agoI suspect that Greenwald is not nearly technical enough to understand the content - not that he's not a bright guy, but the level of technical nuance here might be significant. So then it's all about the quality of the advisors they have access to, but given the nature of the materials, I suspect few people have been able to see them. We just won't know till the whole thing gets released, if ever. And to the second point, obviously I couldn't know for sure, not having seen it, but it's very very common with these types of presentations within government agencies and defense contractors to have 5-10 overview slides, the conclusion, and then behind that 20 reference slides that are more of an information dump. The idea is that the first set of slides is enough for most people, but if you want to dig deeper, there's additional detail.