3 ms·
"Extraordinary claims etc... etc... " Yes, indeed, but I'd submit at this point that the idea that existing GM food is dangerous after being consumed by so man
by jerf 13y ago
"Extraordinary claims etc... etc... "
Yes, indeed, but I'd submit at this point that the idea that existing GM food is dangerous after being consumed by so many people for so long is itself the extraordinary claim. If it's so dangerous, we shouldn't be arguing about it, it should be here. Because we're already consuming it in quantities far, far greater than any possible scientific study could ever bring to bear, and while that does not prove it's absolutely, utterly harmless, it does put a cap on how dangerous it can be.
Arguments implicitly based on the idea that we haven't done it yet and we need to be careful about what we may do in the future are uselessly disconnected from the real world.
It may also be true that it was insufficiently tested before release (I don't know, really), but that does not change the fact that it's out there now, and people are not keeling over dead, and there doesn't seem to be an appreciable signal coming from the GMness of the food in general. Or you'd be pointing to it, instead of theorizing.
- eksith 13y agoThank you for writing a cogent, and much appreciated, calm reply with logic and reason. I can't dispute part of my reply was assertion as well, but (and I'm not making up excuses) I felt pithy remarks for either case weren't helpful.