3 ms·
That GM wheat is someones intellectual property and there's extensive case law of farmers having their lives destroyed by being declared the equivalent of "soft
by VLM 13y ago
That GM wheat is someones intellectual property and there's extensive case law of farmers having their lives destroyed by being declared the equivalent of "software pirates". Its almost an exact analogy right down to small businesses being shaken down for protection money. This is not theoretical or sci fi but established case law and precedent.
Right now there could be an Ag website with a bunch of wheat farmers trying to figure out why anyone cares about a bunch of SCO source code discovered to be contaminating the linux kernel source.
The nightmare scenario isn't even one farmer having his life and livelihood destroyed, but everyone nearby especially downwind is probably shaking in their boots, or should be.
Also using plague language, we have discovered the first patient, but we have not isolated patient zero yet. This may (or may not) be a much bigger contamination.
- StavrosK 13y agoSurely, by discovering Monsanto wheat in the wild, their argument here weakens. Their original argument was that, since their wheat cannot reproduce, it must have been planted by the farmer. And, since the farmer was spraying it with RoundUp, which only Monsanto wheat is resistant to, it's probable that the farmer knew that he was infringing on Monsanto's IP (let's leave the discussion about how ridiculous patenting wheat is for another time). If a mutant Monsanto strain is discovered that can reproduce, everyone can claim they might unknowingly be using that, and Monsanto won't have a case.
- darkarmani 13y agoDoes it matter if you know that you have been infringing a patent? People get software patents enforced on them all of the time that didn't know the algorithm was patented.
- StavrosK 13y agoWikipedia lists a few cases: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto#As_plaintiff http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto#As_plaintiff