3 ms·
The author seems to miss the point. This isn't like Apple emulating classic in OS X (or even PowerPC on Intel). This is Microsoft emulating one operating syst
by wvenable 18y ago
The author seems to miss the point. This isn't like Apple emulating classic in OS X (or even PowerPC on Intel). This is Microsoft emulating one operating system from within another operating system where the compatibility between them is extremely high. You can take most well written XP applications and run them on Vista without a hitch and the situation will likely be better with Windows 7.
So, if the operating systems are so compatible what's the point of XP mode? There's a huge body of badly written software designed for and test only on XP that are necessary for businesses. These businesses haven't just been hesitant to upgrade to Vista, they aren't even considering it. If it doesn't run their app, there's no point. XP Mode is a way to coax them into upgrading by giving them an option to run their old crappy software on this new OS. That is all.
You're not supposed to be using XP mode to run games, so it's lack of GPU support doesn't matter. You're not supposed to be using it to interact with all sorts of devices. That's what the host operating system, Windows 7, is for. If you're going to virtualize everything in XP, you might as well just be running XP.
- potatolicious 18y agoNo matter which platform you're on, there's always this tug of war between back-compat and pushing the state of the art forward. With VM/emulation-based solutions we can now have our cake and eat it too. Why virtualize XP? Simple: version 1 of crappy XP app may only run on XP, but version 2 may run on Windows 7. By pushing apps that refuse to update themselves into a corner, the hope is that app developers will be more motivated to keep their crap up to date, and remove the horrible "meh, we'll call on Win95 APIs" laziness. All this can now be done without harming the consumer (who still gets to run his apps). IMHO virtual XP is one of the more brilliant moves on MS's part in a long time. Their OS has been stagnant for a long time owing a large part to the obsession with backwards compatibility. Thankfully that may now be behind us.