3 ms·
Does anyone notice there's a step missing between "GM wheat found" and "we need to be concerned about it", namely "GM wheat is a cause for concern because <X>"?
by StavrosK 13y ago
Does anyone notice there's a step missing between "GM wheat found" and "we need to be concerned about it", namely "GM wheat is a cause for concern because <X>"?
- contingencies 13y agoBecause it destroys the natural heterogeny of the wild gene pool, depriving us of hardier crops and enslaving us to a corporation whose sole purpose for being is profit-taking, with a short term frame of reference and the minimum of environmental or social concern?
- StavrosK 13y agoAll this because they found a few plants in a field? Wow.
- Ygg2 13y agoKeep in mind that genetically modified wheat is different from regular wheat for the DNA that was added to GM kind. When non-GM and GM wheat combine the results can differ. They can go from a fully functional cross breed wheat or more often (based on documentaries at least) a non-functional wheat plant (leaves growing from where the seed should be, etc), kinda like you breed horse and a donkey and get a mule (it can't reproduce or bear fruit). If it is cross bread with GM wheat it's probably patented by law. If it is non functional it is a direct loss to the farmer. It's really a lose-lose situation. NOTE: there is a chance that GM/non-GM hybrid won't contain any patented genes or be hampered in any way. However in large number of wheat plants you'll notice larger degree of mutants.
- viraptor 13y ago"Because it destroys the natural heterogeny of the wild gene pool" I'm not sure I understand this. By adding a plant with different properties and specific trait you're interested in, you add to the heterogeny of the wild gene pool, not destroy it. It's not like majority of wheat was suddenly replaced with that one ideally cloned plant. If it survives to the next year, it will just mix even more.
- jerf 13y agoThat's not because of genetic modification, that's because of commercial farming practices, which really aren't related. We've done a fine job of homogenizing bananas without any genetic twiddling, for instance. I agree with you that it's a concern, though I'm more concerned by the fact entire crops and indeed potentially entire foods can be wiped out by one pathogen more than worrying about genetic diversity abstractly.
- contingencies 13y ago> ... which really aren't related On the contrary, the GM industry is based upon industrial farming. They are the same environmentally irresponsible, energy-consuming, short-minded, hugely profitable beast.
- VLM 13y agoThat GM wheat is someones intellectual property and there's extensive case law of farmers having their lives destroyed by being declared the equivalent of "software pirates". Its almost an exact analogy right down to small businesses being shaken down for protection money. This is not theoretical or sci fi but established case law and precedent. Right now there could be an Ag website with a bunch of wheat farmers trying to figure out why anyone cares about a bunch of SCO source code discovered to be contaminating the linux kernel source. The nightmare scenario isn't even one farmer having his life and livelihood destroyed, but everyone nearby especially downwind is probably shaking in their boots, or should be. Also using plague language, we have discovered the first patient, but we have not isolated patient zero yet. This may (or may not) be a much bigger contamination.
- StavrosK 13y agoSurely, by discovering Monsanto wheat in the wild, their argument here weakens. Their original argument was that, since their wheat cannot reproduce, it must have been planted by the farmer. And, since the farmer was spraying it with RoundUp, which only Monsanto wheat is resistant to, it's probable that the farmer knew that he was infringing on Monsanto's IP (let's leave the discussion about how ridiculous patenting wheat is for another time). If a mutant Monsanto strain is discovered that can reproduce, everyone can claim they might unknowingly be using that, and Monsanto won't have a case.
- darkarmani 13y agoDoes it matter if you know that you have been infringing a patent? People get software patents enforced on them all of the time that didn't know the algorithm was patented.
- StavrosK 13y agoWikipedia lists a few cases: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto#As_plaintiff http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto#As_plaintiff
- stonemetal 13y agoIf you are a farmer the sue happy Monsanto, or the fact that foreign nations stopped wheat imports means the concerned step is filled in quite nicely. For the general populace GM fear maybe.
- Ygg2 13y agoBecause they are patented property?