6 ms·
Years ago, when Russia was vehemently against US expanding its anti-rocket shields, I was against Russia, and supported US, because "US are the good guys, right
by mtgx 13y ago
Years ago, when Russia was vehemently against US expanding its anti-rocket shields, I was against Russia, and supported US, because "US are the good guys, right?". Over the past few years I've started to understand Russia's position. Nobody should want US to become too powerful, because clearly you can't depend on Americans to keep their own government in check, no matter how good the US Constitution is.
So I kind've understand this move from Russia, too, even though it will probably end badly for Russia, to the point where they become more like China, but I feel that US deserves this from every country in the world, until they roll back all the spying, and end these programs and laws (Patriot Act, FISA).
I imagine that if there are hundreds of corporations lobbying the US government to stop because they are losing business overseas, they will eventually do it, because they know that the end of the day, and despite all their public statements, the spying is not that useful for catching terrorists, and specific investigations and wiretapping should still be possible under reasonable laws anyway.
- colin_jack 13y ago"even though it will probably end badly for Russia, to the point where they become more like China" Not sure what you mean by this. As a European I'm pretty uncomfortable with the idea of a foreign government being able to snoop on my internet communications and I'm hoping European leaders take a stand on this. I don't see that leading any where bad though.
- contingencies 13y agoRussia's best anti-US play right now is to offer massively cheap bandwidth between China/Korea/Japan, South Asia, and Europe. Yes, they will have to look after it. No, it won't be cheap. But in terms of intelligence gathering, it has the potential to significantly impact the US' ease of access to huge bodies of information by cutting North America out of the heart of the internet.
- flyinRyan 13y agoAt this point, I really wish someone would do that. IMO the US has had its time and it's time they started getting cut out more. Having said that, I'm not sure if anyone would trust services coming out of Russia.
- jerf 13y ago"Having said that, I'm not sure if anyone would trust services coming out of Russia." It may be worth reminding people that if the US currently seems to be heading into a police state, that Russia within living memory has manifested one. I'm all for holding the US accountable, but let's not collectively be idiots and think that this is all uniquely a US problem, and that therefore we can just stop worrying about everywhere else in the world and let them do whatever because they aren't the US, they must be awesome. We're still criticizing the US for heading in a direction that quite a few other major countries have already arrived at. It's great criticism, it's legitimate concerns, but don't get overexcited and give everybody else a pass. Can anyone say with a straight face that Russia won't sniff Internet traffic with the same basic purposes and approaches, either now or anytime in, say, the next ten years? I sure wouldn't bet any money on that claim.
- tripzilch 13y agoYes, of course. I'll go one further and say I wouldn't trust any country to not sniff the Internet traffic passing through them. However, spreading it around is at least somewhat better than having the majority of traffic snooped on by a single power. Right?
- contingencies 13y agoThe attraction is that it provides greatly needed decentralization for the internet at large. It doesn't solve the spying problem, but it does contribute to solving the global hegemon with turnkey totalitarian surveillance problem in a meaningful way that both Russia and the rest of the world can derive value from.
- flyinRyan 13y agoIn my opinion the problem is having an entity like the US. If it were a lot of smaller, less powerful countries this wouldn't be an issue. If one of those countries tried crap like this all businesses could just leave. But the US has such a large market, companies are willing to put up with insane amounts of BS to maintain access to it. And let's be honest; at this point only the opinion of the companies matters to the US government.
- colin_jack 13y agoNot sure, I wouldn't be surprised if other regions now take action to stop this happening again. I'm not sure what sort of bureaucratic solution the EU will come up with but I'm hoping they're annoyed enough to do something.
- PakG1 13y agoI think he's talking about how China blocks a lot of American online services. Russia could head in that direction too, though for different motives.
- colin_jack 13y agoAhh makes sense, sorry I presumed he meant in terms of a more repressive approach to communication. I can't see why any governments would be happy with the US monitoring their citizens communication. If the US laws don't change I'd imagine you will find a lot of alternative services having to appear pretty quickly.
- asperous 13y ago> "clearly you can't depend on Americans to keep their own government in check, no matter how good the US Constitution is." The Government has been taking away our rights for years, the general public seems to expect the government to solve all of their problems and give them free paychecks. Of course, I really would be surprised to find out the America is the only country spying on their own citizens. This has been going on for years and everyone knew it.. now with the leak hopefully we can reign in our own government and abolish the practice officially.
- lutze 13y agoSee this? This is part of the problem, stop being so stereotypically blinkered. The rest of the world doesn't care if the US government is spying on its own citizens. The US government is ACCOUNTABLE to its own citizens (well nominally, but hey...), so if they don't like it they're in a position to do something about it. As a none US citizen, I care that the US government is spying on ME, unilaterally and without any accountability. This is what the rest of the world cares about. Stop pissing away what little sympathy you have by moaning like a spoiled child about the bad shit your government is doing to YOU, and open your fucking eyes to what it's doing to EVERYONE ELSE.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- daliusd 13y agoThis move is not from Russia (as country/people) but it is from Russian government. They are constantly doing this as it is the only way to make the look better than they actually are.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- flyinRyan 13y ago>because clearly you can't depend on Any Country to keep their own government in check, no matter how good Their Laws Are. FTFY. The fact is, laws/constitutions/whatever are utterly meaningless. Without enforcement, that is. And it's not up to us to enforce it, it's up to government officials. They can and do simply ignore laws whenever they wish. Sometimes a check/balance kicks in and makes them pay some kind of penalty, sometimes nothing happens.
- znowi 13y agoA bit of history in relation to the proposed anti-ballistic defense system in Europe. In 2002, the US unilaterally withdrew from the ABM treaty with Russia. The treaty had been active since the 70s and sought to decrease the amount of those very systems installed. In the same year, no longer bound by the treaty, the US started to look into expansion of its defense arsenal in Europe, which eventually led them to Poland. It is no surprise then that Russia saw it as an unfriendly gesture at best. Any independent country would, when all of a sudden someone dumps the anti-ballistic treaty and then decides to build a defensive shield along your borders. The EU has traditionally been used as a playground to advance the US agenda. The proposed defense system is no exception. Gladly, it did not come to fruition. Otherwise, we'd seen a very different Europe now. Given our attachment to history, Russia is still often seen as this "cold war" aggressor out to get you. But if the past decade is of any lesson, I think we have a new candidate on this role.
- dhimes 13y agoTotally agree. We have (essentially) all of the military might, start putting up defense shield, then invade the wrong country, against the better intelligence of the Russians and some Europeans. I also sympathize a bit with the Russians for wanting their own checks and balances against the US, as our attitude was clearly "we're going to do whatever we want and don't really care what you think."
- mpyne 13y agoPerhaps surprisingly, but I also agree with the situation from Russia's perspective. There's an argument to be made about ABM against small-state actors like Iran and NK, but any system that becomes a serious deterrent to ballistic missiles puts an incredible upheaval in our "balance of power" and potentially leads to an arms race, increase in conflict, proxy wars, etc. Not good news. I don't agree that Russia should have a say in when NATO would be able to operate such a system, but a notification requirement would be fine, if not actually allowing a Russian liaison to be stationed with the operations center controlling such a system.
- Arwill 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- josefresco 13y agoWhen does establishing a good defense (for an ally no less) become an act of aggression? Certainly it's not a purely passive act, but it's also a far cry from aggression seen by both Russia and the US in the past.
- Mikeb85 13y agoWhen the only thing that prevented war for 50 years was the concept of mutually assured destruction....
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoEspecially including people like Stanislov Petrov's understanding of mutually assured destruction, and his willingness to martyr himself.
- cousin_it 13y agoTwo men have guns. One buys a bulletproof vest. Now he can bully the other one. So, more defenses can lead to more conflict. Also, more offensive weapons can lead to less conflict: One man has a gun. The other one buys a gun. Now there's peace. So many people don't get game theory...
- Fice 13y ago> hundreds of corporations lobbying the US government to stop And then if the government say that they stopped, how can you ever be sure they did? Unless we use free (as in freedom) software, open encrypted communication protocols, and decentralized network services, we are trusting too much of our computing and communication to third parties, which are subject to political powers, that always do whatever they can to protect themselves. The government should not be trusted, it must be controlled. Corporations should not be trusted either.
- pekk 13y agoIf we are talking about being charged with treason and possibly executed, it's interesting to me that you are OK with brutal state oppression in Russia just because it hurts the US. It gives some insight into your priorities: hurting the US is more important to you than whether people are subject to gross injustice by an authoritarian state.
- k2527 13y ago"brutal state oppression in Russia? What the hell are you talking about?
- borlak 13y agoRussia isn't worried about America becoming too powerful. Russia's stance is that your country should worry about itself, and leave other countries alone. Putin has said many snarky remarks in this respect. http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Vladimir_Putin http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Vladimir_Putin
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- stackedmidgets 13y agoTerrorists who are competent harden their communications to avoid US sigint, where the superiority of the US agencies is paramount and well-known. The US is known to have particularly weak human intelligence networks (few spies actually capable of infiltrating foreign terrorist groups). Al Qaeda and the rest know that it's incredibly risky to use electronic communications, so the people that you'd want to monitor already know they're being targeted. Naturally, the US government's response to this has been to bet more heavily on signals intelligence.