19 ms·
You commit three felonies a day
- molf 13y agoSo what are those three felonies?
- kevingadd 13y agoThe first one is asking what the three felonies are. You see, when you were born your parents were sent a National Security Letter (NSL) by the government that stated you can never ask about the three felonies. Unfortunately, the NSL came with a gag order, so your parents never told you. But you definitely shouldn't ask what the three felonies are. The second felony is owning a computer which can be used to circumvent content protection mechanisms. You can address this by purchasing a fixed-function device which cannot be used to circumvent content protection. I suggest an etch-a-sketch. The third felony is
- jlgreco 13y ago"NO CARRIER"?
- einhverfr 13y agoSilverglate talks about a number of cases, some of which have been addressed either before the book was written or after, but the overall problem is still out there. For example, see the honest services fraud charges against Jeff Skilling (of Enron fame), on the idea that anything dishonest any corporate executive might do would be depriving the corporation of honest services. Now the Supreme Court reversed Skilling's conviction on the grounds that this was just too vague and that honest services fraud was limited to kickback schemes and the like. However consider many more: Lori Drew was prosecuted for unauthorized access to computer servers for violating the terms of service of MySpace (iirc). The subsequent directed verdict of acquittal (after the jury convicted) however did not really eliminate the possibility of ToS violations turning into federal felonies. This was not covered in the book but it is worth noting. Many of the examples in the books are profession-related. Silverglate goes into detail on the Hurwitz narcotics case where a doctor who operated in line with emerging best practices for chronic pain management was tried and convicted of drug trafficking on the grounds that he had statistical knowledge of the likelihood that at patients might resell the drugs on the street. Hurwitz's conviction was later vacated, but they tried him and convicted him again of a smaller set of charges. He goes also into medical billing disputes (I have family members who have been on the losing side of these regarding the government and can attest that these are still significant issues). Another case he does not cover is the Joe Naccio case (covered in the link). Another case he does not cover was that of my mother's uncle, who they accused of purjury for claiming never to have been a Communist, when their evidence of his lying was that he was legally representing the Communist Party USA and others as a lawyer. They lost that case but came back one tax issue after another until they found something to stick. There are cases after cases to those of us who follow these things. It is a systemic problem. Keep in mind that under some of these theories of law, checking Hacker News from work when you should be working is a federal felony, and if not honest services fraud, certainly something they could try you with for wire fraud (it is financial in that you are billing your employer for your time!). Moreover if you check a site for non-work purposes which has a note in the ToS which says that unlawful use is prohibited, then you have committed felony computer trespass (because you "accessed" their servers in excess of authorization provided by the ToS in pursuit of criminal or tortuous ends). TL;DR: What felonies you commit are unimportant. If they want to, they will find something.
- Kiro 13y agoNo, I want to know what felonies I commit.
- einhverfr 13y agoSo do I. But the point is that these felonies are largely a product of trying to stretch other laws to cover behavior none of us would consider illegal. However, the big one I would look at in current times for most people is violating web site terms of service. My point is that the mentality is "Show me the man and I'll find you the crime."
- arethuza 13y agoI thought I recognised that quote - it's from Lavrentiy Beria http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavrentiy_Beria http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavrentiy_Beria
- youngerdryas 13y agoBlog spam?
- ownagefool 13y agoPart of the point is you aren't supposed to know, otherwise you'll be able to stop doing them and the authorities will lose their potential future leverage. Another way to look at it is you aren't, but should you come to the right peoples attention, they'll figure out how to bend the rules enough so that you are. No way of really knowing until laws are rolled back, simplified, and followed both from within the confines of the letter of the law and the spirit thereof.
- einhverfr 13y agoAlmost. They aren't discrete things. They need to be laws that can be stretched to include everyone. That way it doesn't actually matter what you do.
- alan_cx 13y ago
- ck2 13y agoAnd the felony history never goes away now. Just think, a child who gets their first smartphone today, will have their entire phone history recorded until death. Their geolocation saved. Their email saved. All their financial transactions. All their friends and family will be known. Every intercontact in society. Where they shop, eat, etc. Who they date. I mean why would the NSA ever delete it? They can just get taxpayers to fund more and more storage. I am also starting to wonder about the new requirement to digitize all medical records and how many contractors will have access to that as well and when all the databases will be allowed to intersect in the name of "security". But I suspect the NSA doesn't know how many guns you own. That alone is somehow seen as a violation of your rights.
- danso 13y agoI've become more bearish about the idea of electronic medical records. The ability for a bureaucracy to keep those safe seems far, far off in the future, no matter what technology advances come through. And guns: well, if you're pro-gun-control, this mindset (justified or not) should help you understand why the NRA is so passionately against gun registration of any kind. In terms of the NSA: I don't think they care much for your felony record -- that is, the ones you've actually been convicted for -- they're more concerned about pre-felonies, of course. For the average citizen, though, the persistence of criminal history is going to be felt in more everyday situations, such as job searches and landlord background checks. If I ever have a child, he or she is going to have a name like "Pat Smith", regardless of my or the mother's last name.
- einhverfr 13y agoWe should all today make a pact to name our children "Spartacus" with no last name.
- Tloewald 13y agoAnd give them burner phones.
- quantumpotato_ 13y ago
- ck2 13y agoBy the way you can start to read the book here: http://books.google.com/books?id=9Au2t9ZOtnAC&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=9Au2t9ZOtnAC&printsec=front... Or find it in your local library: http://www.worldcat.org/title/three-felonies-a-day-how-the-feds-target-the-innocent http://www.worldcat.org/title/three-felonies-a-day-how-the-f...
- Uchikoma 13y agoFrom Atlas Shrugged: “Did you really think that we want those laws to be observed?” said Dr. Ferris. “We want them broken. [...] There’s no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren’t enough criminals, one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws.”
- jacquesm 13y agoIt may help to remember here that Ayn Rand wrote that stuff as an ex-citizen of a country with a communist regime that employed exactly those tactics against their citizens, I highly doubt that she intended or foresaw those words to be used against the rulers of the country that she chose to live in.
- reneherse 13y agoBut then, she also wrote Atlas Shrugged as a kind of warning, with the hope that we would not become the kind of regime she fled. The OP is exactly apropos.
- fexl 13y agoThat's right, and it was set in America.
- noarchy 13y agoThe context you've mentioned is important. I'm not a fan of Rand's overall philosophy (sympathetic to parts of it, perhaps, but that's not terribly important), but surely one can appreciate this quote in the appropriate context, even if they reject the greater body of her work.
- pietro 13y agoAtlas Shrugged is set in the United States. I'm sure she wouldn't be surprised.
- ubernostrum 13y ago
- meerita 13y agoA state that monitors without limits is dangerous for several reasons. Mainly because those who watch may or may not alter its ethics, for example, for personal gain. Someone with access to data can fuck another. A typical example would be a company, which is surveilled and they know all their movements, communications, contracts and any possible information that a government can sell to competitors or people who pay for this information. Amen to these problems will also be those, as noted in this article, the issue of being "possible guilty" all the time is just plainly sick.
- trustfundbaby 13y agoAnyone who's had their company try to get rid of them is keenly aware of this on a micro scale. Its amazing how many weird rules and regulations you can suddenly find yourself afoul of once somebody high up enough has it in for you ... apparently this is true on a macro level (country/government) too.
- emmelaich 13y agoSee also Ham Sandwich Nation: Due Process When Everything is a Crime http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2203713 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2203713
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rmc 13y agoSometimes I get a whiff of nostalgia from posts like this. As if everything was great back in the good old days, where the police weren't able to hassle you, when laws were fair and simple. Of course that was only if you were a white anglo cis straight christian. Anyone who didn't fit that was able to be prosecuted/killed/oppressed/jailed. But if we pretend those people don't exist, then everything was great in the past.
- coldtea 13y ago>Sometimes I get a whiff of nostalgia from posts like this. As if everything was great back in the good old days, where the police weren't able to hassle you, when laws were fair and simple. People keep repeating this reasoning. I can't understand why. "Everything" doesn't have to have been "better in the old days", and nobody, except strawmen, argue that. But SOME aspects of the old days, e.g pertaining to LESS fucking SURVEILLANCE, were. That's enough to be angry about and want to reverse course on that particular front. >Of course that was only if you were a white anglo cis straight christian. Which is totally beside the point. Did somebody argue here that slavery was good? No, people just argue that modern surveillance (and legal-code-overload) is bad. Not to mention that surveillance today is bad for everyone: "white anglo cis straight christians", homosexuals, blacks, and what have you. We should not mix up orthogonal issues.
- rmc 13y agoThere was lots of government surveillance and invasion of privacy of (say) gay men back in the "good old days". Maybe it's just because the white anglo christians are affected by government surveillance and intrusion that's new? My point isn't "this old thing was bad", my point was "this thing has been happening to lots of people before, now it's happening to everyone".
- coldtea 13y ago>There was lots of government surveillance and invasion of privacy of (say) gay men back in the "good old days". Maybe it's just because the white anglo christians are affected by government surveillance and intrusion that's new? My point isn't "this old thing was bad", my point was "this thing has been happening to lots of people before, now it's happening to everyone".* For one, if it happened to "lots" (in reality: far fewer) and now is happening to "everyone", this extension of reach automatically makes it far worse. Second, even considering a single target person, the breadth of this, the automation, the easiness, and the retrieval and cross-search capabilities, make it several orders of magnitude worse than what was happening to people before. Compared to the breadth, scope and capabilities of modern surveillance, J.E. Hoover was a total amateur. Also "government surveillance" of "gay men"? When? For who? A few prominent figures people wanted to blackmail?
- knotty66 13y ago"If you would give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest man, I would find something in them to have him hanged."
- ex_ex_nihilo 13y agoCardinal Richelieu, if I'm not mistaken.
- Perceval 13y agoAttributed to, but disputed in its authenticity.
- nutate 13y agoCompared to the 300 things I could get sued for daily, I think I'm probably doing just fine odds wise.
- kolinko 13y agoThere was a soviet saying - "Give me a person, I'll find you an article/a paragraph". Meaning - for any person, finding a law that the person breaks is just a matter of time and resources. It's interesting to see Americans discover this...
- mpyne 13y agoIt's not new to Americans either, despite how stupid we're considered by the rest of the world. There's been news articles noting the same issues with the complexity of the legal code since even before 9/11. Any student of the law has undoubtedly been aware for decades prior, when they had to research volume after volume of legal decisions and statutory code to establish what precedent (if any) to use in helping decide a later case, and what laws (if any) applied.
- gambiting 13y agoAs a person coming from a former soviet republic, I am very familiar with the saying "show me a man, and I will show you the crime he is guilty of" - which basically meant that if KGB wanted to charge you with something, they always could find a paragraph for you, because there were so many and so vaguely defined. As an outsider, to me it seems that the USA is not a "free" country and I honestly don't see any difference between what the US and Russian governments are doing to journalists and people who disagree with them. Edit: Oh, and we already had massive surveillance back then. If you wanted to travel out of your town - you had to register that fact with the nearest police department. Wanted to travel abroad - had to apply for a passport, which was only issued for a strict number of days and had to be returned upon return. If you were placing a phone call, it would always start with a warning "This call is being monitored. This call is being monitored". The post office would open your parcels and letters. There was book censorship on a massive scale. What the US government is doing has already happened. "Those who don't remember history are bound to live through it again".
- JamisonM 13y agoThis is a false equivalence. Just the fact that the US government feels compelled to hide a program like PRISM is a strong indication that there is a big difference between the Russian government and the US government (and certainly the Soviet government). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_in_Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_in_...
- JanezStupar 13y agoThere are better and worse slave masters. But slave master is a slave master still.
- pekk 13y agoIf you are working at will for pay, you are not being enslaved. Get a grip.
- 13y ago
- ccera 13y agoI read that book when it came out. The title is sensationalist garbage -- the book shows how some people get snared by some fairly stupid federal laws and have their lives messed up by willfully malicious prosecution, which isn't good, of course, but nowhere does the author demonstrate how an average person commits three felonies in a YEAR, or in a LIFETIME, let alone in a day.
- ape4 13y agoMany people have software that isn't totally licensed.
- chunkyslink 13y agoIs the USA now a tyranny?
- kyllo 13y agoI'm not so convinced Nacchio is an innocent victim. And I also find it rich that a former telecom CEO guilty of numerous financial crimes is being held up as an example of targeted political persecution using frivolous laws. Insider trading is not the type of crime you commit unknowingly. Has anyone even refuted his guilt convincingly? That is a serious crime and also one with a clear paper trail. If he did it, there would have been no need to frame him for defying the NSA; the SEC would have got him soon enough anyway.
- moron4hire 13y agoInsider trading is only a crime when people want to find you guilty of a crime. That's why congresscritters are not prosecutable for insider trading. Insider trading is the entire point of trading, you wouldn't make any money if everyone had the same information.
- kyllo 13y agoPerhaps those with the right type of political power/influence are able to shield their trading activity from SEC scrutiny. But trying to use this guy as an example of the "You commit three felonies a day" argument? Really? Do we all commit three felonies a day unknowingly? Maybe. But the suggestion that tens of millions of dollars in insider trading falls into that category, is flat-out demented.
- moron4hire 13y agoNo, you're missing the point. It's not about obscuring anything from SEC scrutiny. The SEC sees everything that is going on. You don't even have to have used insider knowledge to be tagged with insider trading; the SEC says that it's enough to have had access to insider information to be guilty of insider trading. It does nothing about it because it would render Wall Street moot. Insider trading is so vaguely defined and broadly applied that it is a rule meant to be broken so they have something to blackmail you over when they decide they want to shove you around over something else.
- mpyne 13y ago
- brianberns 13y agoSo what are the three felonies a day that I supposedly commit? Article is quite short on details.
- gasull 13y agoThis is why "nothing to hide" argument is wrong.
- saraid216 13y ago...while I don't find this implausible, must the only provided example be a CEO?
- diminoten 13y agoNot new, such has been the case for most of human history. An honest man is most able to live in the US without being harassed or condemned, more so than at any other time in history. I'm not saying we're done, or that it can't still be bad because it's better than it was, but it's worth remembering that this isn't a solved problem that we're just "too stupid/lazy/greedy/corrupt" to fix. I'd even go so far as to argue that it's human nature to build governments where this is true, and it will never not be true. A critical part of our justice system is the discretion of those who enforce, legislate, and interpret our laws. You can't pretend like laws exist outside of human (read: flawed) implementation, and I feel that this is more severely perpetrated by those in STEM fields because they're used to the rigor that comes with such disciplines whereas the law is a fluid and changing beast.
- guyal 13y agoOther than refusing to consent to letting the NSA wiretap your customers, what 'innocent' actions can be viewed as felonies? I didn't see any specific examples which applied to everyday life in the article.