2 ms·
Saying the NSA doesn't care if you've smoked weed is like saying the telephone doesn't care if you've smoked weed. It's technically true, but you can still get
by Alex3917 13y ago
Saying the NSA doesn't care if you've smoked weed is like saying the telephone doesn't care if you've smoked weed. It's technically true, but you can still get arrested for things you say over the phone. Same with the NSA, where they don't actually enforce the laws themselves, they're just a data provider for everyone else. And even if no one cares now, when the data is stored indefinitely, things you're doing/saying now that are completely innocuous could be used against you years or even decades in the future. Ex post facto won't stop the government from banning you from getting on a plane, getting a passport, taking out a bank loan, etc.
- tptacek 13y agoI think if you look at all the comments I've made on this thread (I'm not asking you to, just saying), you'll see that I agree that there is data any American might want to hide in their telephone calls or emails. The issue is that NSA doesn't want that data, and that FISA was designed to prevent data from being used the way you say it could be. Long-term storage of data is certainly a valid issue. Of course, under FISA, NSA is obliged to "destroy" all data they accidentally collect that can't be traced to a specific foreign intelligence purpose.