5 ms·
I have no data to back this up, but I suspect you are wrong. I believe that the majority of American adults (let's say age 18 and above) are guilty of many crim
by baddox 13y ago
I have no data to back this up, but I suspect you are wrong. I believe that the majority of American adults (let's say age 18 and above) are guilty of many crimes and that the NSA is very capable of obtaining evidence to convict them. Some of these crimes people are well aware of, like drug use, speeding, or the obvious copyright infringement, but some aren't, like tax crime or breaking safety regulations.
As the quote goes, in a closed society where everybody's guilty, the only crime is getting caught. And when the government already has all the evidence it needs to convict everyone, then anything can essentially be made illegal by selective prosecution of unrelated crimes. Have you been protesting against the government's foreign policy? Suddenly you're in jail for the mistake you made on your taxes 5 years ago. Have you been active in an alternative currency like Bitcoin? Surprise, you're in jail for that movie torrent you seeded a few months ago.
- tptacek 13y agoFor starters: the NSA can't convict anyone; it doesn't have that power. Next: no matter who obtains information under FISA and how it's obtained, it can't be used as evidence in court unless the proceeding pertains to the objective of the FISA warrant, which itself must pertain to agents of foreign powers. If evidence of, say, drug trafficking is collected against you deliberately via FISA, you can move to suppress that evidence and courts are required to do so. If evidence is collected accidentally against you via FISA, the USG is required to destroy that evidence.
- baddox 13y ago> For starters: the NSA can't convict anyone; it doesn't have that power. That's true (right now anyway), but I don't buy the idea that government agencies (or even branches) are distinct enough that we shouldn't be worried. Similarly, I wouldn't approve of the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service employing a network of domestic assassins, and the fact that they are currently not legally permitted to carry out assassinations would be of no consolation.
- tptacek 13y agoIf you think the NSA is going to sprout (say) a drug enforcement arm, why are you so worried about telephony metadata? Clearly, there's no law constraining NSA at all; were I you, I'd be more concerned about them disappearing me for making public arguments against them.
- baddox 13y agoI am more concerned about them disappearing people for making public arguments against them, although I suspect I would be nowhere near significant enough for anyone to notice.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm always interested in people who think like this. If the NSA --- or for that matter any other part of the USG --- was "disappearing" people, what does it matter what FISA says, or how much metadata they're collecting? Clearly no law we have has any impact on them at all.