2 ms·
But most people really don't, and especially not from NSA. How can we say that though, when we don't really know what the NSA is collecting, what they are doin
by mindcrime 13y ago
But most people really don't, and especially not from NSA.
How can we say that though, when we don't really know what the NSA is collecting, what they are doing with it, who they are sharing it with, etc.? The actual data collection per-se aside, one of the biggest problems with this whole setup is that we have allowed the development of a "shadow government" (not in the conspiracy theory sense, mind you) that lacks effective oversight (Congress is not sufficient oversight in my book), and is barely - if at all - accountable to the American people. Between the NSA, the CIA, the FISA courts, and FSM knows what other agencies - as well as "National Security Letters" and "gag orders" - we have a monster on our hands that we barely know anything about.
- tptacek 13y agoWell, stick me at the place on the Venn diagram of Americans who: * Have a problem with the NSA getting wholesale access to telephonic metadata for all domestic phone calls. * Generally do not believe NSA is using that metadata for purposes other than nonproliferation and counterterrorism, where "counterterrorism" means "pursuit of groups with active plans to kill American citizens". * Agree that the shortcut NSA appears to be taking around existing due process is going to be a problem in the future if it isn't addressed and restricted. Also, I find the number of acronyms we're tossing around --- NSA, FISA, FAA, &c --- comforting, not alarming. There's a lot of process here. Some of it is really bad and needs to be fixed. But in the 1950s, we had no process; the USG just listened to everything.
- mindcrime 13y agoFair enough. I also doubt that the NSA - as an agency in general - are using their snoop data for "purposes other than nonproliferation and counterterrorism"... yet. And while it's admittedly hypothetical, it's that "yet" that concerns me. But fear of how government collection of personal data can be misused is not without valid precedent: see the reign of J. Edgar Hoover, for example. Who knows, maybe the political winds shift in, say, 5 years, and it becomes very dangerous to have certain ideological beliefs, or to have said certain things. I'm not crazy about making it easy for these guys (doing the whole "we were just following orders" thing, possibly) to go on a wholesale fishing expedition to find people to start giving the "yellow star" treatment. I know, I know... way hypothetical, and you could argue "paranoid". Unlikely, even. But just because something seems incredible or unlikely doesn't seem, to me, to be a good argument for making it any easier for that scenario to come to pass. :-)